mardigras |
07-25-2005 04:37 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunni
And btw. if witnesses don't matter in the judical system in America,
|
Good lord, where did you ever read that into anything I said? Of course witnesses matter in the judicial system in America (as well as forensic, photographic and other evidence) but nobody decides a case before all that evidence has been presented and all of the witnesses have been heard from and their statements compared to other evidence for collaboration.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gunni
Basicly I am saying that the eyewitnesses are the evidence
|
No, the witnesses are a part of the evidence.
If person A says "This is the guy I saw robbing the bank" and there is a video showing clearly that it was not him, should he go to jail because the witness was "sure"? CourtTV has run a number of excellent programs showing how faulty eyewitness testimony can be, where different people remember completely different heights, weight, clothes, hair color, actions, the whole 9 yards.
You were not there. You cannot pick one witness over another from news reports to believe. There are too many things in this case that just don't add up and they won't even start to add up until there are some pictures or official witness transcripts or something released... it's quite possible that key evidence won't be known by the public until the family has them subpoenaed in a civil suit.
|