Miss GFY - Should she be disqualified or not?
 

Big debate in our office.

Argument for disqualification:
Some think she should be disqualified because the GFY logo is not in the pic and "it's a given" that it should be.

Argument against:
The rules do not say you have to see the logo.

Let the masses decide!

Make no mistake, she is hot as hell! But do no vote on that.

Here are the Round 3 instructions:
ROUND THREE CHALLENGE: This rounds challenge is to produce the best pic of yourself in the GFY tank top and panties. The best pic wins the $500 round 3 prize. 10 Girls will be knocked out this round. Since we are mailing the clothes, the round will end on June 11.


http://www.missgfy.com/round03/images/11.jpg

i say you break the rules you are out
they are called rules for a reason.

GF who?

let her stay.

i think the pic is hot. who cares if you cant see the logo, you can assume they are the proper thing.

I think that as much as it is a great image and she looks great.....I thought the point of the pic was to be seen in our GFY tank & thong...and nothing in that image shows that she is really wearing it...I own lots of white tanks & thongs..

In the spirit of GFY , my opinion is that the full GFY logo on the tank and the thong were supposed to be included in the image. That's what I thoght when I shot mine....wouldn't have done it any other way !

:2 cents:

Ivy

Round 3 sure has been interesting...lol

Yeah, when I first saw that pic, my initial thought was "I don't see GFY anywhere in that pic at all."

I think to be a "miss" anything.. you have to be representing what you're going for. You can be damn sure a "miss coca cola" would be required to have the coca cola logo very visible in every pic.

I mean, I love the pic and all... but I'd have to go with "DQ" on this one. The logo should have been visible.

Rules are rules, and the rules did not say they had to see the logo. They say you have to wear the tank and thong .. She is definately wearing it.

Whether it's a "given" or not, doesn't matter. When you have a contest, the rules have to be clear, otherwise there are no grounds for disqualifying her.

edit: I should note that I agree that it is a given and she SHOULD be showing it, but that doesn't make the fact that the rules never specified it, any different.

I agree. While she's very pretty, she could be wearing any similar outfit. There was a long-time member and contestant (sorry I can't remember who offhand) who had to drop out because she didn't get her outfit in time. She could have just as easily wore something else that was similar but she wanted to comply with the rules. It isn't fair to the girl who backed out to allow someone else who isn't showing the logo to stay in. :2 cents:

of course not

i even vote this pic!

let her stay, but consider this as a warning :winkwink:

WFT? There was nothing in the rules about having to show the Logo. If there was I would have done that. I have some other pics from that set that have the logo on it I would have submitted that one if I knew that. :(

can't she make a new picture?

You can "think" what you want to...but the unpopular position will be that you didn't specify it in the rules...so how can she break a rule that does not exist?

stay :)

everyone deserves a second chance make her resubmit a pic with logo shown

"The rules do not say you have to see the logo."
:2 cents:

if you wanted the logo's showcased you should have said so, no need to throw someone out because people are crying about it now.

Well, if it wasn't IN the rules, then no, she didn't break the rules.

On the flip side, every other submitter realized they needed to have the GFY logo shown (in fact, I believe several said they picked pictures based on how well it was shown).

I'm going to abstain from voting on this one - it needs to be a Lensman decision :thumbsup

I have some pics from that serie that have the logo on it. I will post one in a few seconds I need to upload it

yah but she does have a nice ass maybe give her some time to submit a new one ? :thumbsup

I vote to let her stay.
:glugglug

Pretty simple, I believe it would be a mistake on your behalf, not hers.

i agree..


technically she did not break the rules.

If she can post a pic out of that set with the logo on it, let her stay........:glugglug

I like the Pic. but i agree with Ivy!!
:2 cents:

Maybe just require another pic that just shows her holding them with their logo's showing, just to prove she did infact have them.

i'll protest if they throw you out or disqualify you, we'll all quit voting.

I went and looked at the site and it read:

ROUND THREE CHALLENGE: This rounds challenge is to produce the best pic of yourself in the GFY tank top and panties. The best pic wins the $500 round 3 prize. 10 Girls will be knocked out this round. Since we are mailing the clothes, the round will end on June 11.

and

Each contestant is to send in a pic of themselves wearing the GFY tank top and panties that will be mailed to them.


I think technically she did what the instructions required. She's wearing the gfy tank and panties (unless you think she's lying about that part), so I don't see what you could boot her for. I honestly would have never noticed it if it hadn't been pointed out.

Boy...I've done tons of promo shoots for companies in a white tank & thong printed on the front with their logo....I bet I could have used one of those behind shots then, noone would have known the difference !!!

Ivy

I will post a pic that will show it in this thread. Why would I email Loryn that I got the stuff, then go look for something that looks the same and wear that in a pic???

btw this thread is extra advertising for the girl (no offense Bo :D)



But i want Vanilla to win :Graucho




tb

and no one would have cared, just like we didn't care about this and it's gay that it's even brought up.

I think she should be disqualified.

The picture is Hot as hell and she looks great.

However, all of the girls made an effort with their creativity to make sure the GFY logo was shown.

If the other girls had the opportunity not to show the logo, perhaps their creativity wouldn't of been as limited.

It is not fair to the other girls.

really you shouldn't even bother defending yourself, it's gay that this is brought up. i am positive it wasn't lensman that thought it up, but it was brought to him.

Let her stay. It's already been said that she didn't break any rules and if you wanted the logo to be in the picture that should have been stated.

LOL what's funny is you know exactly how the women in the contest will vote...evil pure E - V - I - L
:1orglaugh

I definitely see the side of the argument that states it should be a "given" that the GFY logo should be seen .. however, I am a purist .. the rules made no clear statement requiring it, therefore I do not feel it fair to disqualify her.

Maybe you could reach a compromise and have her re-shoot the photo? I think that would appease both sides.. and in the future make sure it's stated as a rule.

Just so you know we already have our winner. This is an issue of DQing her or not.

missgfy participants want her out.

why im not surprised? hah