Recommend Good Video Editing Software for Win Vista?

[RevengeBucks_Monica]

So I'm on Windows Vista and I'm rather disgruntled to find that Windows Media Encoder doesn't work properly (even after installing the released fix). I'm also having trouble with some other programs.

I need video editing software that will enable me to encode for various file types, edit the video (such as make short clips), and set various compression rates and file sizes.

Does anyone have any recommendations for something that works well with Vista?

[Twoface31]

use vegas thats cool

[Sands]

VideoCharge might have the range of functions you're looking for. I use it to transcode videos to different resolutions and formats, as well as string clips together when necessary. I think you can cut clips with it as well.

[Tat2Jr]

Originally Posted by RevengeBucks_Monica

So I'm on Windows Vista and I'm rather disgruntled to find that Windows Media Encoder doesn't work properly (even after installing the released fix). I'm also having trouble with some other programs.

I need video editing software that will enable me to encode for various file types, edit the video (such as make short clips), and set various compression rates and file sizes.

Does anyone have any recommendations for something that works well with Vista?

I hate to say it, but the best thing you can do is to stop fighting Vista and do a fresh XP install. Then all your tried and true video programs will work just like they always did. Best thing I ever did was "downgrade" my Vista laptop to XP.

[natas]

Originally Posted by Sands

VideoCharge..... I think you can cut clips with it as well.

you can indeed, it's a great program and well worth the money imho

[Sands]

Here's what I did:

I acquired and installed a second hard drive and installed Ubuntu on it. Then I installed ffmpeg and ffmpeg-php, and wrote myself a nice little web app to coordinate the conversion/thumbnailing process. Though, it might be more than you're looking for.

[candyflip]

For what you are looking to do, VideoCharge is the tool.

[JayS]

I use TMPGEnc 4.0 XPress from pegasys-inc.com, it works fine with Vista.

[fris]

i use videocharge, i love it

[Jim_Gunn]

I still have all my pc's on XP because I have so many video editing and encoding apps that I don't want to mess with my "upgrading" to Windows Vista. But if Videocharge works with Vista (I believe it does) that is a good app to encode video and split up clips. For actual editing, you may need to look into a full featured editing app like Adobe Premiere Pro or Sony Vegas.

[thehand]

Originally Posted by Tat2Jr

I hate to say it, but the best thing you can do is to stop fighting Vista and do a fresh XP install. Then all your tried and true video programs will work just like they always did. Best thing I ever did was "downgrade" my Vista laptop to XP.

Word, Vista would be great if it worked.

[RevengeBucks_Monica]

This is the only thing that has given me any trouble on Vista so far so I'm not keen on downgrading to XP just yet.

So does VideoCharge work well with Vista then? It sounds like most people recommend it.

I was looking into Premiere, but I've heard mixed reviews on it.

[Jim_Gunn]

Originally Posted by RevengeBucks_Monica

This is the only thing that has given me any trouble on Vista so far so I'm not keen on downgrading to XP just yet.

So does VideoCharge work well with Vista then? It sounds like most people recommend it.

I was looking into Premiere, but I've heard mixed reviews on it.

I love Premiere Pro. You can hit me up with any questions you have on it, Monica.

[tony286]

if you have vista 64bit vegas has a version just for vista 64

[stickyfingerz]

Originally Posted by Jim_Gunn

I still have all my pc's on XP because I have so many video editing and encoding apps that I don't want to mess with my "upgrading" to Windows Vista. But if Videocharge works with Vista (I believe it does) that is a good app to encode video and split up clips. For actual editing, you may need to look into a full featured editing app like Adobe Premiere Pro or Sony Vegas.

I use mostly the same work flow as you Jim. It all works with Vista now. I've been Vista only since I think Feb or March. WAY less issues with crashes etc that I had when using xp pro.

[tony286]

Originally Posted by stickyfingerz

I use mostly the same work flow as you Jim. It all works with Vista now. I've been Vista only since I think Feb or March. WAY less issues with crashes etc that I had when using xp pro.

Bill must of given you the magic special version of vista. lol

[stickyfingerz]

Originally Posted by tony404

Bill must of given you the magic special version of vista. lol

Or I have my system setup properly the way its supposed to be setup and have all the proper drivers installed. No fucked up ancient hardware etc. Running on 3 computers and none have crashed since I switched to Vista. Lucky me I guess. SOMEHOW all my stuff runs faster, and smoother using Vista than it did with XP pro. GASP!

[Jim_Gunn]

Originally Posted by stickyfingerz

I use mostly the same work flow as you Jim. It all works with Vista now. I've been Vista only since I think Feb or March. WAY less issues with crashes etc that I had when using xp pro.

I have several pcs in my office all running Win XP with little or no issues. It's not just Premiere Pro that I use Stiicky, I have older apps that I rely on like Cleaner XL 1.5 and some smallish programs too that I have no idea if they would migrate to Vista successfully. If for no other reason than wanting to avoid putting myself through the hassle, the only compelling reason to upgrade my four main pcs to Vista is if a new version of a major software app like Premiere Pro comes out that needs Vista or works better with it. Other than, I figure better is the enemy of good enough since i have everything working right for HDV editing and encoding.

[stickyfingerz]

Originally Posted by Jim_Gunn

I have several pcs in my office all running Win XP with little or no issues. It's not just Premiere Pro that I use Stiicky, I have older apps that I rely on like Cleaner XL 1.5 and some smallish programs too that I have no idea if they would migrate to Vista successfully. If for no other reason than wanting to avoid putting myself through the hassle, the only compelling reason to upgrade my four main pcs to Vista is if a new version of a major software app like Premiere Pro comes out that needs Vista or works better with it. Other than, I figure better is the enemy of good enough since i have everything working right for HDV editing and encoding.

Ya I held off for a long time. I use cleaner too, and sorenson 5. Plus frameshots, and videocharge, and boilsoft splitter, and a bunch of other small software like that. All of it works awesome with vista now. Some of it didn't when I was first dual booting Vista. Thats why I had to wait a while for the full switch over. Now I only have one XP computer in the house and that is Dixie's. We are buying her a new one within a month, and it will be Vista too. XP leaves the building.. hehe

[candyflip]

Originally Posted by tony404

Bill must of given you the magic special version of vista. lol

I'm a diehard Mac user who still uses Vista and has not ever had a single issue. My girlfriend manages a training center on at an Ivy League university and installs Vista on Mac machines day in and day out. She too has never had a single issue with Vista.

I'm pretty much convinced that people who lay the hate on Vista are either spouting off info they heard or read elsewhere and haven't had much real interaction with Vista.

[Spike D]

Originally Posted by Jim_Gunn

I love Premiere Pro. You can hit me up with any questions you have on it, Monica.

And if you do not need the power of pro, Premiere Elements can do everything you are talking about for a lot less $...

[munki]

I'm on Vista ultimate 64bit on all machines now, and given proper hardware, setup, and plenty of memory you can't beat editing and dumping with Premiere and After Effects. The workflow is amazing once you get it down. I've eliminated most of my outside software besides VideoCharge on occassion for small quick jobs.

If you need simple, they've got it covered, if you want to tweak every details it's all there.

Adobe Suite Vote +1, though if you can wait, you might want to hold off for the new CS4 release... I'm hearing great things.

[RevengeBucks_Monica]

Thanks Jim, I will take you up on that someday! And thank you to everyone else for all of your suggestions and comments, it's very appreciated. I think I will check out premiere and see what I think.

[Bird]

Originally Posted by candyflip

For what you are looking to do, VideoCharge is the tool.

you video charge

[RevSand]

I am picking up a copy of videocharge now... I keep hearing great things about it and have been wanting to and never the time to play with it..