Who Is The Greatest Qb Of All-time
 

My Friends And I Have Been Arguing This Topic In Drunken Rage For Days...need To Know Others' Opinions.... I Think Joe Montana Followed By Tom Brady And Then Steve Young...what Do You Think?

I would say:

1. Joe Montana
2. Johnny Unitas
3. Brett Favre
4. Troy Aikman
5. Steve Young

Aikman? Maybe Playoff Qb

P. Manning
Montana
Favre
Marino
Bart Star

Honestly you have to say Marino. He holds an incredible amount of records but was never given the team around him to win it all. Give him the Dallas team that Aikman had and he'd win the SB. Give him either of the 49er teams that Young or Montana had an he'd win the SB. Hell make him the QB in Buffalo instead of Jim Kelly and they would have won 4 in a row instead of lose 4. :2 cents:

Joe Montana

Good Point On Marino....but Still Never Won

If I added the rest of my top 10, it would look like this:

6. Tom Brady
7. Dan Marino
8. John Elway
9. Payton Manning
10. Randall Cunningham (he paved the way for the new generation running quarterback)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Mar..._by_Dan_Marino

With Joe montana a close second as he was able to win period.

warren moon should be tossed in with randall :2 cents:

By the end of Peyton's career, there will be no doubt he's the greatest QB ever.

yes Joe Montana is the greatest QB ever

You guys are obviously too young to have this conversation, or you should reword it to, Who is the greatest QB in your lifetime?

Rex Grossman :1orglaugh :1orglaugh

Roger Staubach and Troy Aikman would both be on my list

The only time I really took an interest in American Football was in the early 90's I think (might be late 80's). The names I remeber are Dan Marino, Joe Montana, Jay Schraeder (sp?), John Elway.

So Im definately not the one to ask.

(also remember the fridge, the ikky stomp?, Mike Ditka, Jerry Rice, and that fugly who made some crappy films called boz).

the icky shuffle.........and stone cold with the boz ruled:321GFY :1orglaugh

Hmmmm....let me guess your favorite team :)

:1orglaugh :1orglaugh :1orglaugh

John Elway. Hands down the best. Your list tells me you know nothing.

That's a tough one to figure out, isn't it? :winkwink:

Terry Bradshaw should be thrown in there as well as Roger Staubach

Broadway Joe Namoth

Dan Marino
John Elway
Joe Montana
Terry Bradshaw
Brett Favre

as much as i hate marino he has to be in the top 5.. of most peoples list.
elway, montana, young, UNITAS

and dont forget Fran Tarkenton

Fran Tarkenton could scramble like no one else.

id go for Joe Montana.. even if he doesnt really win..

Aikman, you must be tripping.

Steve Young shouldnt be in the top 5 either. Dan Marino should defintely be up there before both.

IMO


http://imagecache2.allposters.com/im...le-Posters.jpg

Bradshaw's stats actually suck except he has 4 rings.

Peyton mannings at 64% completions which is the highest in NFL history !

Some of the big name QB's are just that Big Names because they won some super bowls but their stats aren't the best !

winning does make the diff . . . stats are just stats . . and wins are wins . . can't argue about that . . it's a team leadership quality that marino didn't have

Either Montana or Terry Bradshaw.

Montana for me

john elway!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
brett favre no. 2

It is way to hard to really measure, specially with the sheer number of rule changes that have gone into effect since the late seventies early eighties. I am not to sure if some of the listed top QB's stats or longevity would of been as good as they are if everyone played under the same rules.

Joe Montana

Then....

Dan Marino

John Elway

Fran Tarkenton

Tom Brady

Peyton Manning

This I agree with.

I think separately Dan Marino but since he was so greedy they never could geta good team for him to do anything with.

So his flaw was greed not skill.

Eric Hipple

http://www.morgannews.us/eric-hipple.jpg




















:1orglaugh probably not on the list

Jim Zorn

Are you fucking kidding? Joe Montana by any sane person's judging is the best quarterback. Honestly, the question should be "who is the 2nd best quarterback of all-time?" because Joe Montana is a sure thing at #1...my list is pretty acurate as far as names on the list. Where someone chooses to put those names is personal preference.

Aww shucks.

you mentioned randall cunningham and warren moon with the greatest qbs of all time?
the goddamn post was best qb's
this is not a part of affirmative action
get a fuckin grip bro

Aikman wasn't really that good. :2 cents:

Top 10

1. Dan Marino
2. Payton Manning
3. Joe Montana
4. Brett Favre
5. Fran Tarkenton
6. John Elway
7. Warren Moon
8. Johnny Unitas
9. Tom Brady
10. Dan Fouts

Depends on what people consider the "best" as. Best all around QB talent-wise? Best stats? Best in the clutch? :2 cents:

how can u leave steve young out of your top 10. He was deep with his drop in the pocket accuracy and his running game. Alo filled the biggest shoes! Did I leave out his 6 TD's ?passes in the "94" SP

I didn't mention Warren Moon in my top Qb's...I simply mentioned Randall Cunningham not for the fact that he was a black quarterback but for the fact that he changed the game as far as a new breed of running quarterbacks are concerned (which nowadays is becoming the norm)

1) Joe Montana
2) Tom Brady
3) Jim Kelly

RACER

Jim McMahon was the greatest QB of all time........



















































well, maybe just for 1 season. :1orglaugh

Another QB who was the best ever for only one season:

http://sportsmed.starwave.com/media/...s_rypien_i.jpg


Mark Rypien