NFL: Kyle Orton VS Jay Cutler
 

Part of this was posted in the superbowl prediction. I am seriously shocked at how many ppl think ortan sucks and cutler is better. Lets take a look at stats here.

Kyle Orton's rookie year 05 he started in 15 games and took the team 10-5. His rookie year, he took Chicago to the playoffs. Measuring Orton's victories, his rookie season was successful. His 15 starts and 10 victories are both rookie records for Bears quarterbacks, and the 10 victories are the third most in the NFL, since 1970. hmmm feeling stupid yet?

Jay Cutler's first year as a starter not a rookie mind you. He took the denver broncos for a whooping 7-9 wins.

Now let us compare the two's last two years.

09 Orton led the Broncos to a surprising 6-0 record to begin the season.Ortans first interception was game 6 against the new england patriots. After his injury he did not perform as well but still did amazing. The broncos had gotten rid of there star receiver and HAD NO RUNNING GAME. Orton threw 21 touchdown passes and 12 interceptions with an 86.8 QB rating.Orton had 3,802 yards 541 passes of which 336 of which were complete. (hmmm, getting yet?)

Jay Cutler took the bears for 7-9 and 27 TD, 26 INT. His 26 interceptions led the league. Culter had 3,666 yards with 555 passes 336 of which were complete.

since i already proving my point ill make this fast because I am sure you are finding it hard to follow.

10. Orton finished the season 3,653 yards 20 touchdowns, nine interceptions. He missed 3 games at the end of the season, and the broncos only won 4 games last year. Only 186 yards was rushing combined Almost every game was extremely high scoring game regardless of the fact that he was sacked 34 times. There was no run game and sure as hell no defense. RUSHING (Plays-Average Yards) 398 - 3.9 531 - 4.7 the broncos only had 398 - 3.9 compared to its opp which had 531 - 4.7 yet the broncos had a passing yards that beat most teams TOTAL PASSING YARDS broncos 4038 opp combined 3780. qb rating 87.5

Cutler, yes the bears went to the playoffs, but how much did he really do? Lets take a look. Ive proven maj of you idiots wrong esp from chi and den, try and prove me wrong.

With a 11-5 record cutler did 3,274 23 TD and 16 INT. Cutler has a comp of 261 out of 432 attempts with a finished qb rating of 86.3. (side note) in pass yards bears were ranked 28th in the nfl and broncos despit only winning 3 games were 7th. RUSHING (Plays-Average Yards) 414 - 3.9 386 - 3.7.not a huge difference in average yards but when u look at the opp u can see the difference in defense. TOTAL PASSING YARDS 3015 3588.

I am getting sick of writting this and its stupid if anyone thinks cutler is a better. When he has more tools and better around team.

ppl ask me why i care? i care because im a chicago fan that saw many seasons wasted on rex and orton no chance to shine when he proved he has talent.
__________________

isn't cutler the guy who whimped out last year in post?

Yes sir our 3rd.string played better

Now hold on a sec, he had a serious knee injury.:1orglaugh:1orglaugh

Lol atleast I can say one good thing about another team and that's chargers qb he played injured and I battered. I've seen prying play limping as well. Cutler is a fluke another qb draft that was a.bad idea. You will see how many years Orton starts compared to cutler soon enough. Orton will be put on a team where he is treated right and on a team that doesn't suck and use Orton as a fall boy. I hope he goes to flordia better yet detroit because that would be awspme to watch cutler finally realize how.much he sucks

Hasn't Brett Favre been playing with sand in his vagina for the past few seasons?

Yes I should of mentioned him but he is retired. I will say I respect the fact that the old mans best session was 2009-2010. He should of retired then. Man what a year.

They both suck but if I had to choose I'd take Orton he has more heart.

Being that I live in Indiana and got to watch Orton when he was at Purdue, I can say the guy is a stud. He has been on shitty teams and thus we haven't really seen his potential. He is underrated and hasn't been given any respect in the league. I'd take Orton over Cutler and Tebow.

Cat shit vs dog shit.

You are comparing to shitty qb's? :1orglaugh:1orglaugh

I like the guys who never watch football are experts on Cutler's injury during the NFC championship game.

That was his planting foot and Cutler had virtually no time in the pocket as is. They made the correct call pulling him. After the half the medical / coaching staff let him try to play with his injury but pulled him after it was clear as day he was totally ineffective. Go back and watch the game again.

There was no "whimping out", Cutler took more hits than ANY QB this season.

Taking statistics from various seasons on different teams is so irrelevant it's not even funny. Protection, wide receivers, coaching strategies, etc, etc can make or break a QB's statistics in any given season.

Cutler brought the Bears to the NFC championship game, is he better than Kyle Orton? Not sure about that. Is he basket-case? I don't think so....

Beating the Eagles who were on a hot streak coming off huge wins against Atlanta, NYG and Indiana.



Great game against the Jets who were playing great football beating the Steelers the week prior.



Then solidifying the 2nd seed in a 3TD performance in fridget conditions.



Then beating the Seahawks who were coming off a win against the SB champion Saints.



I like Jay Cutler, but then again, he's the ONLY Bears QB to throw 3,000yards in back to back seasons, EVER. So maybe we are content with mediocrity. :action-sm

they both suck. but orton has exceeded his nfl expectations while cutler has been a failure on top of being a douche bag in general...

i'd rather have a tough, hard working qb with mediocre talent (orton) than a pussy ass diva bitch with a strong arm who makes mistake after mistake any day of the week (cuntler).

you can post a million videios, hell. a trillion. cutler still won't EVEr have post season play.

I can understand why ppl may think orton is a shitty qb because he hasn't not made it far but as a rookie did something only another 3qbs did. In both 09have and 10 put up more yards then most quarter backs and has had better td vs int rating then moat abs. While both seasons he wastop 5 sacked qb and both seasons had no defence or run game to help. With all that I say he's an amazing qb and he is just starting. For example for only winning 3 games as a starter in 2010 he was ranked 10 in abs in the nfl and only played 14 games one he was out almost entire half??? Amazing in my nook

after that performance cutler put on in the playoffs last year id take orton over that prick any day.

the guy fucking quit on his team.

He's got to keep his post season no loss record in tact somehow.

Hey buddy, if you bothered to watch my "million videios" you would've seen the last one was post season play.

Once again, people who DON'T watch football always like to chime in and give their two cents. :1orglaugh

Another guy who doesn't know shit about football or the Bears. :thumbsup Cutler might make a lot of bad decisions and he isn't the best QB, but if you knew a SINGLE thing about the Bears you would know he took the BIGGEST ass kicking in the last two seasons. He is the opposite of a quitter, once again, he's taken more hits than any other quarterback in the league yet he always rose up and gave it his all even with virtually no protection and mediocre wide receivers running ass backwards routes.

Why don't you take a look at the Vikings game when we were already in the playoffs, he played with a huge gash in his chin in -30 degree weather on a frozen turf to secure a 2nd seed spot. Fair weather football fans are a joke. :)

I still love the bears and always will but why not a fan support the players they want. Just like im pissed they ditched Olsen.

i watch plenty of nfl. as much as i can. i don't feel the need to be a walking nfl encyclopedia when it's all a mouse click away.
fwiw, i'm just stirring the pot, op seems prety gung ho on cutler, posting that 2x, i was messing with him.

either way, cutler still has an attitude problem, or at least comes across that way.

i enjoy watching and chatting about it but i leave the expert commentary up to super fans like yourself

why are you spending time comparing two QB's who when all is said and done won't be remembered as anything more than mediocre?

in other words, who cares?

I'm a little bit of a super fan, but not so much a walking NFL encyclopedia. :thumbsup I just watched enough Bears to know that Cutler is far from a quitter. He might be a lot of other things....:1orglaugh

Who cares? Bears and Bronco fans. Not all of our home teams have Peton Mannings and Tom Bradys.

I'm pissed they ditched Olsen too. Martz is a moron, he had a ton of potential but he ditched him because he didn't fit into his style. He wants a TE that can block first and catch second, not a good enough reason to dumb Olsen if you ask me. :(

Cutler was sacked 52 times last year *ouch*

not even close to the record though, David Carr sacked 76 times in 2002.

As a Denver fan I have seen both Culter and Orton play many times. They are very different QB's but personally I believe they are both underrated.

Orton is a proven winner who understands what needs to be done to win the game. Cutler has the ability to throw on the run and throw back across the field in a way that is unmatched in the NFL (except by Michael Vick).

Orton needs a team with a strong running game and a conservative coach (ironically like John Fox), and Orton needs an offensive guru like Mike Shanahan to take advantage of his unique skills. Mike Martz always tries to force his players to fit his system (which will not work with Cutler). They need a coordinator who will tailor his system to Cutler.

Definitely not the record, but he led the league last season. It just goes to show his toughness though, despite getting hit countless time with often no protection at all he had a decent season. When someone says he's a "quitter" it's just a joke. :upsidedow

Cheers. :thumbsup