person A puts blackberry on table, person B spills beer- who pays for new Blackberry?
 

that's the question.

Person B legally.

Assuming nobody caused person B to spill the beer.

Person B obviously. Seriously I think a test should be administrated before people are allowed to use the internet.

get an iphone problem solved, but person b

top answer

Insurance on the phone?

relax there tough guy, i'm just having a little fun after a rough nite of partying.

Person B pays, thats all there is to it.

if you cant hold your fucking drink, you are held accountable for what you fuck up.

Sorry my fingers got the better of me :(
I am going to shut up now and do some work.

person b

yes, $50 replacement.

so no worries on either side.

but we did get into a drunken discussion about the matter, since person A does assume responsibilty for where she puts her blackberry. if she chooses to put it on a bar table, she incurs all responibilty for damages and releases her drunken party, including peron B, from any liability other than buying a round of shots.

:1orglaugh

ONLY A FUCKTARD WOULD BRING A BLACKBERRY INTO A BAR.

:2 cents:

Whoever is the better brawler.

You put electronics on a bar table then it's your own damn fault.

Sounds like the OP was thinking about taking a friend to small claims court or something. Take the sim card out, put it in another phone, and don't flash your phone (especially something lame like a blackberry) around any more - keep it in your pocket. Nobody has been impressed with phones since 1996.

Fuck the blackberry.

Who's replacing THE BEER!?

Depends where the table's at. If it's at a bar/club it's your own fault.

Person C ????

:thumbsup:thumbsup

i would just go buy myself another phone... not sit there and complain that someone else buy one for me.

depends on what kind of beer

Yes Ill leave my 300.00 blackberry phone in the car while im in the bar... Its retarded to say you don't bring your phone into the bar. My phone comes everywhere. lol And yes its a blackberry. lol

the real tragedy is the spilt beer, who cares about some douchebags blackberry?

we all know you're person b

Phones don't belong on public tables where drinks are served. You park it there at your own risk.

It is a normal hazard for spills on a table. It is also bad form to put electronics on a table.

Its probably like 8 years since someone spilled a drink at a table I've been at. Ill risk it. lol

Why the hell would it even be on the table? My blackberry stays on vibrate in my pocket, it's quiet, non intrusive, and has no chance of getting fucked up.

i'm actually person c. however, person b spilled MY beer on person A's Blackberry. i didn't want to make it confusing for peeps here, so i kept the explanation simple.:1orglaugh

If I spilled beer in someone's phone I'd buy em a new one and I would expect the same.

I have caused much wreckage through drnken clumsiness and have always made amends. The end.

but is that becuase you're allways sitting on your own?

Rofl. Ya thats it. :1orglaugh

:thumbsup

person b.

Person b.

Person B is not responsible because person A was a fucking idiot and put his phone in a place he/she knew could get fucked up. So now it becomes everyone's responsibility to watch out for the person A's blackberry and person A. is left out of it all because he/she should not have to watch their own shit? Person B is not required to replace the blackberry, but to be a nice friend person b can pitch in half to help person A get a new one.

Person B is not required or responsible to get person A a new one. What if it was stolen off the table? Who is person A gonna blame for his/her stupidities? Unless person B spilled the drink on the blackberry intentionally he/she is NOT responsible. As I said, offering to pay half for a replacement should be sufficient and person A should be happy with that.

Have a reliance for that?

First question, but then it just changes to who pays the deductible.
Absolutely.

Better be person b

If spiller is drunk, then should accept responsibility, but even more reason to not leave it on the table.

Contributory negligence.

I was poring myself a shot of Patron and a tiny bit splattered on my one day old BB... it ate holes in the screen where it hit... so now I have 3 spots on the screen about the size of a pin head. Yes... I was drunk. We were in a hotel room too... I didn't get it replaced... I just use the fucker as a reminder... don't drink Patron again... it can eat holes in a fucking cellphone screen... :D

I agree I can see if its in someones house or your own home but in a bar. You put it down your problem.

If you're ever partying with a bunch of people who, like you, are drinking - then you put your phone right out on a table, you're asking for drunken mistakes to befall the phone.

I say person A. If it was a sober environment, then person B.

:1orglaugh

Person A, don't leave your valuable lying around where they can get beer spilt on them.