:1orglaugh :1orglaugh

The Clash SUCK. You've gotta be kidding - they're not even in the same ballpark - not even in the same universe musically.

That's punk "music", not rock. Punk was founded on the belief that you don't even need to know how to play an instrument to be in a band. Bah, no thanks. :disgust

There's a difference idiot and obviously you're to young to realize this. Brittany Spears is heavily marketed, Zeppelin wasnt. Zeppelin shyed away from publicity and they became what they were through their talent, Brittany through her looks and marketing. In 30 years people won't know who Brittany Spears was, nor the Clash. They both suck, got it?

I have to disagree that RMW is the best rock song ever. With that said I'm a HUGE Joe Walsh fan. I love that guy. His old stuff with The James Gang is the shit. :thumbsup

BEST ROCK SONG: Hotel California :2 cents:

No shit. That Flock of Seagulls crap is all but forgotten.

you need to go listen to the clash, and understand their impact on music. you are obviously clueless.

i love how people who have apperently never listened to punk can so easily define what it is, and why it was started. it's much more complex than tha, and really had nothing to do with "not knowing how to play". you have no clue.

hahahaha . . . you make all those valid comments, then end up with a ballad by the Eagles?

Their impact on music? Okay, what artist has said that the Clash was who they got their motivation from?

I've heard entire Clash albums - heard entire Sex Pistols albums - heard entire pop punk albums from Green Day and Blink 182. I don't especially like any of it - Green Day's new stuff is all right.

Sid Vicious was quoted as saying he liked punk because you don't need to know how to play an instrument to be in a punk band.

They were all about stripping it down & just being noisy, not talented. Some people like that style, to me it ain't shit. The Clash had some decent radio songs but to compare them in any way to Led Zeppelin, who were musical geniuses, is pure insanity. Every single member of Zeppelin was amazing - they covered every style of music and did it all well. They revolutionized rock music and redefined the genre forever.

The Clash had a couple of "ok" songs - they shrink to a inconspicuous speck under the towering shadow of Led Zeppelin.

I'm clueless and yet you think the clash has more talent than zeppelin :1orglaugh

Is your name your drug of choice?

True.

Zep in the 70's is much like NWA in the 80's in that respect. Both groups received virtually no radio play but sold millions of albums anyway.


"[Zeppelin] rarely gave interviews, since the music press detested the band. Consequently, the only connection the audience had with the band was through the records and the concerts." - http://www.vh1.com/artists/az/led_zeppelin/bio.jhtml

That song rocks. Nobody said it had to be an up tempo song, and that's not really a ballad. A ballad is a SLOW song. "Beth" by Kiss is a ballad. "Faithfully" by Journey is a ballad. Hotel California rocks.

But if you must...

Dazed and Confused - Zeppelin

or

Master of Puppets - Metallica

many bands, from metal to pop rock.


sidney was an idiot. the only reason the pistols worked with him on bass was because jones and cook had great checmistry together.

sorry i guess i just prefer good quality music that is written abuot something meaningful.

it's amazing how defensive people get when you talk negatively about led zepplin. it's like you asll knwo they suck, but are afraid to admint it. :1orglaugh

no my sig is my drug of choice. ;]

I think the top 2 songs played on rock radio are:

Zep - Stairway to Heaven
Eagles - Hotel California

I think Zep had the lead for years but the Eagles song has now taken #1 spot as the most played. Each song is kinda mellow (minus the latter parts of Stairway to Heaven). Both good songs but wouldn't be near my top choices.

Got the same taste.... :thumbsup

Christ, this is about as worthwile as trying to tell a kid candy is bad for them.

well, to be honest, i asked to see what other people thought, not to hear your vagina's bleed about my pick.

As much as I must disagree with smack regarding the mighty Led Zeppelin, I will say that the Clash is one of the greatest bands I've ever seen live.

"Clampdown, Joe! Fucking Clampdown!"

and i'm certianly not denying the importance or influence of led zepplin. i just don't think their music is good. ;]

Has anyone mentioned freebird by Skynyrd?

= huge too.




The clash, athough good in their niche and have some great songs, are nowhere close to being in the same strata as Led Zep.

That's just the way it is. Poll any cross-section of 50 million people from N American, UK, Aussies etc and the answer as well as the song will always remain the same. :D

Zeppelin received as much radio play as any huge rock band in history. So much so that Detroit rock stations refused to play stairway to heaven sometime in the early nineties. They were accepted enough by the critics to be inducted to the rock hall of fame.

Stairway to Heaven came out in 1971 and you're making references to a radio stations decision on airplay 25 years after that. Whats your point?

Stairway to heaven

Mike33 said Zeppelin got little radio play and still made millions. They sold millions of records and enjoyed constant airplay throughout the seventies and eighties. Led Zeppelin is the most popular rock band of all time and wouldn't have reached that status without the radio.

1) Siouxsie & The Banshees - Cities in Dust (<-Click To Listen)
2) Siouxsie & The Banshees - Kiss Them For Me (listen)
3) Sir Mix A Lot - Baby Got Back
4) Sir Mix A Lot - Buttermilk Biscuits
5) Sir Mix A Lot - Posse On Broadway
6) Sir Mix A Lot - Square Dance Rap

"diamond ring" of BonyJovy and "November rain" Guns'n'roses

last time i checked, sir mix alot wasn't rock. :1orglaugh

I like a bit of zep and a bit of the clash. Funny how punk gets a bad rap from classic rockers. In particular the clash. Download White Riot and 1977. Double A-side from 1977. Killer. The whole point of punk was that ideas and energy were more important than how well you can play your instrument.

My current top 5 "classic" rock:
1) Soon - My Bloody Valentine
2) Marquee Moon - Television
3) Judy Is A Punk - The Ramones
4) Transmission - Joy Division
5) Gimme Shelter - The Rolling Stones
6) Tomorrow Never Knows - The Beatles
7) Snowblind - Black Sabbath
8) Fools Gold - The Stone Roses
9) I Wanna Be Your Dog - Iggy & The Stooges
10) Golden Years - David Bowie

Great stuff ;)

one fiddy great songs.

how you remind me - Nickleback

I wanna Rock!

Twisted Sister!

Eye of the Tiger - Survivor

AC/DC rocks. Yeah. Hard to choose a song from 'em though.
TNT possibly :)

A day in a life The Beatles