Marines will defend to the end thier comrades they rely on that in combat and in the rear everything marines do is based on a buddy system

So you support lynch mobs do you?

This is something that each individual has to resolve themselves to do. I can't make anyone do anything, all I can do is hold myself to that standard and hope others follow my example.

I prefer hangings myself.

there will be an internal investigation and his commander will discipline him befor he gets that opportunity to go in front of a judge


you cannot be punished twice under the UCMJ Uniform code of military justice

I got my ass saved once thanks to this clause wasnt for somthing this bad but it saved my hide ;)

The guy who got shot was obviously involved in a gunfight, and knowing that he was still alive and could be hiding a gun/explosives is haunting to anyone. If you're a marine and you have those thoughts in your head, it's either him or me, well you know what the choice will be.

Innocent civilian?? Wasn't Fallujah pretty much evacuated weeks ago leaving just rebels in the city. I think the probability is pretty high that whoever was shot killed in that video was involved just before in an attack against troops or at one point had a gun firing at troops. NOW for all the hating retards out there, think of this. If this guy was a rebel, which, in all likelyhood he was, he at one point was firing a gun at US troops. He got what he deserved, plain and simple. I wouldn't have ANY mercy for anyone who pointed a gun at me. Let me tell you something else, if I had to make a quick choice on whether I make sure this poncho is dead, or have him take my life with his bomb belts/hidden guns, you damn be sure that he's going to hell first.

Actually, you can be punished twice. He can go to captain's mast (or GQ) as well as a courts martial. His commanding officer does not have the authority to punish him for executing a wounded prisoner. He does have the authority to punish him for a more minor offense.

1. Not all civilians left, lots of them refused to evacuate.

2. Even if he was a combatant, he was unarmed, wounded and detained by previous troops, which that later platoon was relieving. That's still executing a prisoner, which is against the Geneva conventions.

Not trolling, just genuinely curious because I don't know how I would respond. If they found a bomb on this guy afterwards, would your reaction be any different?

You are the terrorists. You are killing children in Iraq. WHY????
For every child you kill I hope 1 million of you will die. The world would be a better place without you fucking uneducated/bible/christian/pedo mothefuckers.

Spoken like a true jihad. Hey, Allah spoke to me. He said you will go to heaven if you strap a bomb belt to yourself and blow up a crowded metro/building/arena/airplane/cafe etc...Go my son, go, go do great things with your life like become a jihad warrior like your father.

I don't see how he would have had a bomb, because he was severely wounded and thus would have used it on the previous platoon that captured and detained him. He didn't, therefore it is extremely unlikely that he had a bomb.

You avoided the question. I said IF.

Spoken like a true prodigy :thumbsup

"great spirits have always encounterd violent opposition from
mediocre minds" /A.E

every time i am stresses it makes me feel better when i shoot some unarmed people...

I find the most effective stress relief is shooting little kids. And bombing neighbourhoods. That usually leaves me cheering and wanting more.

wel semiautomatic weapon and a trip to high school is a vacation for me!

shut up asshat!

I think the only people who get upset about this and the Abu Ghraib torture are the ones who think that Americans are somehow morally superior to other people. For me I'm not shocked at all. Humans do terrible things in wartime. Don't think American soldiers executed Nazi prisoners of war? American soldiers are human, not angels of mercy, and that's what humans do. If I were in that position, sent to some shithole on false pretenses, getting shot at, getting my buddies killed, I'd shoot that guy too. He could've surrendered before the firefight started. After that it's fight to the death.

if a mutherfucker is shooting at me, do u think i give a flying fuck about the geneva convention, im killing that mutherfucker which ever way i can.

war is not fair.

and this shit happens all day everyday, just some asshole captured it on tape.

News crews should not be at frontlines...
People can not handle what war is. But then again it's good to point out to the dumb assholes that voted for Bush what they have endorsed...

I am just wondering why the building was not just leveled from the get go to remove all doubt of possible danger's.

I believe it was a mosque.

Am I the only one here who cannot decide whether the marine is to blame?

NO. It's hard for me to decide if he was wrong also.

One thought I can't get past is why the insurgent just laid there motionless. If he had thrown his hands up (maybe he couldn't) and surrendered I doubt he would have been killed.

He moves = he dies .... + threat.

or he was incapable of moving because of wounds...

You seriously need a 762 lodged in your skull.

Ad3pt:

Do you seriously expect anyone who has remained dying on a floor for at least 24 hours to be even aware an asshole is pointing a gun to his head??

Surrendered? Have you actually seen any of that tape?? There was no question of surrender - these people were dying - they could not give one fuck about "surrendering".

Copies of the fuller version of the tapes are now being checked out my more expert people in London. The initial remarks are on the observation of US troops and their ease with the way this incident happened.

Concerning the action as viewed on TV - that is considered a war crime, no doubts, ifs or buts. Apparently the action is only at the base funamental level of that which is considered a war crime and all forces know this very well. ie. It is not an incident where there is much room for doubt.

There appears to be little doubt there is a serious problem and may extend beyond the murder of that one person, but also of others in the vicinity as well as abuse of prisoners.

Who knows..time will tell.

So come and "lodge 762 in my skull" you fucking monkey! WTF does that mean anyway? English motherfucker! Do you speak it???

I tould you before and I will tell you again. You can some over here and try something. Just don't forget to bring your whore wife with you so we can double fuck her in the ass over and over again.

http://www.southo.net/crap/info-smilie.gif http://www.southo.net/crap/info-smilie.gif http://www.southo.net/crap/info-smilie.gif

donnie:

Why bother?? :-) You are wasting effort responding to an utter imbecile who has no relevance to anyone or thing.

Ad3pt:

Yet another meaningful post from a piece of shit? :1orglaugh

My.. your contribution to GFY is overwhelming!

Ad3pt:

Mmm.. Yea.. applies to you are well...

Try actually absorbing it - ya may at least learn something.

http://www.southo.net/crap/info-smilie.gif The Americans are killing unarmed civilians, gassing the resistance fighters, and losing this battle. It's true I read it on islamonline.com!

:1orglaugh

Ad3pt:

What are you raving on about now imbecile? :1orglaugh

Clearly you are more than just retarded..

Is your dick really as big as your idiot brain?? :glugglug

Are you gay?

Are you arab and gay?

Or, are you just a selfowning http://www.southo.net/crap/info-smilie.gif ?

I didn't vote for Bush, and I don't support the war. I do support our troops.

I don't support the death of 3000 people on 9/11 - you apparently do, making you a terrorist, ergo - the pot calling the kettle black.

Reading through the rest of this thread, it's obvious you are a troll/board personality. I apologize to everyone for feeding you.

Please take your meds, or die. Either is acceptable.

Ad3pt:


As I said before... you are an utter irrelevance to anyone.

Just an imbecile.. fuck knows why you are even here. :1orglaugh

Try wasting some more time on southo.net and at least get some decent website operating with content, rather than a load a email links...

Sheesh.. more than useless. :1orglaugh

Answer the question ownagemastah hahahahahahahaha> http://www.southo.net/crap/info-smilie.gif