For all the young people in this thread saying they'd go.....

Are you prepared to get hit with machine gun fire, and as you are laying there in a pool of your blood, knowing you are about to die, say to yourself "this was worth it, it's for my country" ????

I don't think so. You'd be thinking "FUCK MY COUNTRY, FUCK THIS POINTLESS WAR.... Please, I don't wanna die yet". That is the reality.

You think soldiers at war are fighting for their country? They aren't. They are fighting for THEMSELVES and each other to live to see their wife, kids, family, friends, job, etc...

This isn't the movies. You don't go over there and kill kill kill and probably not get hit yourself, and then come back as a hometown hero. In a major war, good chances are there that you come back deaf, missing a limb, in a wheelchair for life, or worse.

Yeah, you may be missing both legs, but it was for your country! Right?

You're talking hypotheticals.

Besides, war is always engineered by those who benefit economically or politically. I'm suprised by your level of conformity.

If you do not love your country why are you living there? If you do not benefit economically in your country why are you living there. Your country is not run by a dictator. You are free to leave it if you choose to.

So if one loves their country but hates the leaders and their policies they should leave? Is that your idea of freedom?

Well, yes and no. Of course I'm talking hypothetically with regards to the present situation. WWII on the other hand was not hypothetical. The part that was, was the part about you living during that time, but it is a valid point. Back then there WAS a draft, and it defiinitely WAS to directly defend your country. (and mine) I am surprised by your lack of patriotism bro. I'm a Canadian, but sometimes I get the feeling I'm more of a patriotic American than many Americans I talk to. And I think you are missing my point.

Tell me,... do you feel that your country is worth defending? Also, do you think it is up to you to decide which war your country needs you for? If 20 million arabic soldiers were to land on East Coast USA, my question to you is, would you get off your fucking draft-dodging ASS and fucking defend your nation??

Please, just answer the question.

So ... you enlisted, backed out of it, and you are proud of it?

He is Australian and does not like the USA.

Uh, CD ... we are more likely to be simultaneously invaded by Mexico, Canada, and Uranus before there are "20 million arabic soldiers ... land[ing] on East Coast USA."

If you love your country and are going to reap the benefits of living there do you not owe your country and countrymen something in return ie when the country calls for your service? In the USA if one hates their leaders and their policies then don't vote for them, but in the meantime one does not get to pick and choose what laws he/she is going to obey and what laws they aren't, just because you do not like your leaders or their policies.

He can just sub in "Australia" for "USA" then, and my question still stands. I really wonder what he'd do if, say, 100,000 Al Quaida terrorists invaded the Oz "gold coast". Would he go surfing, or hide in his basement?



Australia was probably LEAST likely to be affected directly during WWI, yet their country sent a TON of armed forces to fight the Germans. I've done a fair amount of reading and research on that war, and I don't recall there ever being anything mentioned about Aussies dodging the draft. Men from ALL the countries of Great Britain went to war to pretty much clean up the planet, period. That was one of the dirtiest bloody wars ever fought.

fuck no! I already know how to shoot a rifle. If I get drafted, I'd be there. So, it's really just a matter of time...can all these mother fuckers take us on?...no!

That's really not the point. That ficticious scenario goes directly to the question...... "if enemies were directly threatening your country, your city, your neighborhood, WOULD you fight to defend it?"

Just because you live in Comfortable US of A doesn't mean you couldn't have just as easily been born in a country where war IS a reality.

And never say never. No one thought Rome would ever be defeated or successfully invaded either.

Although the likelihood of a draft is rather dismal in light of the adequate recruitment numbers generated by the military, I would still answer the draft.

I personally think its hypocritical to enjoy the benefits of a society and refuse one's duty to defend it. My attitude towards this, admittedly unpleasant, duty is similar to my attitude towards taxes--I hate paying taxes, but I still do, because its my duty. Instead of not paying taxes because I think they are too high, I still pay them but make damn sure to vote Republican to help reduce taxes. That's the difference... disagreeing with a war is one thing, but shirking your duty to the society that has benefited you for so long is another.

Just my :2 cents:

Never though of this b4, but I'd have to agree 100fucking%, go and fight on someone else's soil, they'd have to drag my fat lazy ass all the way there, assumeing I didn't fail a physical, whihc I'm sure I would, or end up dead/in military jail, for beating to death someone trying to force me to do something I don;t want.

But, put some fucker in my home town or anywhere on Canadian fuckin soil, point me in the right directtoin and I'd kill the fucker with my bear hands if I have to.

I am a mother, No I don't want my children in the war. No I don't want my children to die no mother or father want that. The idea is that I die before my children. No I don't want them to come home in a body bag

My sisters husband is from the old yugoslavia, his brother went back to get belongings and other stuff. He was shut in the head and thats less than 1 year ago.

If their is a draft we have no choice than to let our children go. Israel and Palastina has 13 and 14 year olds walking around with guns, growing up with them, its a sad world

Persia teaches weaponry in school

Would my boys go and not run. Probably,
Would I agree - NO
Would I sit back and take care of their business - Sure

The new Draft - discussions are already in the making

http://www.dailytexanonline.com/vnew.../3e3e237449ad1

search the net about it and you find out that quite a few politicians are for the draft. Is it going to come?

I hope not

LOL Doggy :1orglaugh
Oz
...:::SEVEN:::...

I would give my life for the ones I love.
I would give my life for my ideals.
I would give my life to protect my freedom.

I would NOT give my life for international politics and western megalomania. If I was drafted, I would fight for my freedom, or die trying.