Compare these tgp's

[slainwayne]

My partner says simple is better his tgp is up on al4a
http://www.al4amovies.com/gallys/svf/sv007x/
I don't know how to design a TPG but here is mine:
http://www.subvisionfilms.com/logos/post2/toursvf.html
I need help in determining which is better.