Here is my free 2 cents worth...
I just read all 5 pages of this. 3 of the pages were nothing more than bashing each other and a total waste. If your gonna bash each other, start your own thread. This thread was started with a damn good idea this industry needs.
I agree with everyone else that their needs to be some way to investigate who goes on the good or bad list. If not, then this is going to become a joke. If you want to put someone on the shit list, you must provide 100% proof to backup your claim.
I think their should be a vote on who goes on each list. Naturally, their would need to be safe guards in place so the ballot box doesn't get stuffed. I also think the 'voting' can only be done by webmasters. We deal with these companies daily. Only we know who is good and bad. If surfers are involved, then their will be abuse to this process.
Anyway, this is a good idea. I hope it happens.
