The Soviet Story
 

Just watched that documentary... The idea of giving birth to a new man makes sense... but killing 20m people? Sick.

Trailer: https://youtube.com/watch?v=sqEf2FSbrdY

They also show Russian politicians still using Nazi salutes and people are being murdered the Nazi way in Russian federation. Considering their population and resources, these lunatics are a menace to the whole world.

:disgust

In 1933 they exterminated Ukraine by cutting off all food supplies. 7m people starved to death... in one year.

who are "they"?

The Soviet leaders? People who supported maxism... Lenin, Stalin... Oh come on, I though you were from Russia, shouldn't you know better?

man, i found this site that had the letters from all the officials in the ukraine during that bullshit.. intense.

that would be Stalin forcefully introducing 'equalization'

I just wanted to clarify that you talking about “soviets” in particular. Some people have difficulty differentiating between political and racial groups that were in charge during those times.

If you asked Ukrainians lots of them would tell you that Jews did it. :(

I'm going to watch Hitler In Colour tonight. Heard Germans murdered 50m for that same idea of giving birth to a new man.

20 Million people murdered, 20000000! No funerals, no memorials, no nothing. What the fuck :disgust

You're too emotional. You'd better learn history and think to make up a conclusion than watch some controversial stuff.

:thumbsup

I read Wikipedia every day.

Not even a decent burial in many cases.

http://www.odkrywca.pl/forum_pics/pi.../wianuszek.jpg

By 'Nazi way'? The Soviets invented the 'Nazi way' - the famine already pointed out is just one example of that. If Nazi Germany hadn't of started a world war in Europe the Soviets would of done so in short time anyway, they wanted a bolshevik world after all. The US, England, etc decided to make a deal with the devil, a devil who was no less evil than Hitler by ANY means, but perhaps the head of a less advanced, less threatening regime. The UK could of chose either side, Nazi Germany very honestly wanted peace with England, instead they chose to side with the Soviets. I guess in hindsight they got it right, the USSR, for all its glory was far less powerful than a Nazi state encompassing the same land would of been.

It's Poland, not Soviet Russia. That's what Ukrainian nationalists (not Soviets/communists) did to Polish children. Learn history.

By 1933 Lenin had been dead for 9 years.

And that is relevant because Lenin's version of the Red Terror was more humane than Stalin's version? :disgust

I stand corrected then.

I've seen that same picture attributed to a variety of events including the Russian civil war (Reds vs. Whites) and the Red Army's advance into East Prussia some 25 years later. More often though, I've seen it attributed to the various internal Soviet crackdowns of the 1920's and 1930's.

Be that as it may, the pictures below are clearly more on target.

http://svetbezkomunismu.cz/galerie/rusko/sssr_06-1.jpg Samara area, 1921

http://svetbezkomunismu.cz/galerie/rusko/sssr_01.jpg Ukraine, 1932-1934

http://svetbezkomunismu.cz/galerie/rusko/sssr_02.jpg

The source for these images is here.

It always has been a fucking cruel world out there, and it always will be :(

are you a total fucking retard?

did you skip history class in school?

all this is some new revelation to you?

jesus man. what the fuck is wrong with some of you people????

what the fuck does Stalin have to do with anything in the world TODAY????

:Oh crap:disgust:Oh crap:disgust:Oh crap:disgust

Tis True, The Nazi's fucked up firstly by dismissing the alliances of England, France, Spain, Itally and America. That was the number one mistake. Nazi's got land for Peace, and Independence from the rules of WWI Treatise. Nazi Germany had excellent trade with America and most of Europe after WW1 and even during the Preamble to WWII, the relations were solid and made great economic sense for everyone. The Hindenburgh did not burn in Germany it Burned in America.

The 2nd Mistake Nazi Germany made was killing the Jews.

IF Nazi Germany did not do both of those things Nazi Germany would exhist today and perhaps would have been Allied with most of Europe to thwart the Communists of Russia.

If that had happened far less people would be dead than what has happened in reality.

The Nazi party was not always a Dictatorship either. Hitler made it a Dictatorship at the onset of WWII. The Nazi Concept is a parliamentary system of government, it works its solid in every respect to fair governorship of a people and it works for the people under it.

More people should read about what Nazi really is because the Nazi Government system has the labor force 100% in mind with fair pay for fair work.

You are moron Sir. Why? Because you have no idea who are "they". If you read something about golodomor's history, you'll find out that an author of the idea to cutting all the food supplies was an Ukrainian man. Furthermore, we was not just an Ukrainian, he was a nazi-Ukrainian one. Wanna know his name? Wanna read about it?

The term Weimar Republic is used by historians to signify the democratic and republican period of Germany from 1919 to 1933.

Following World War I, the republic emerged from the German Revolution in November 1918. In 1919 a national assembly convened in the city of Weimar, where a new constitution for the German Reich was written, that was adopted on August 11. The first attempt to establish a liberal democracy in Germany failed with the ascent of Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party in 1933. Although technically the 1919 constitution was not invalidated until after World War II, the legal measures taken by the Nazi government in February and March 1933, commonly known as Gleichschaltung, destroyed the mechanisms of a true democracy. Therefore 1933 is usually seen as the end of the Weimar Republic and as the beginning of Hitler's so-called "Third Reich".

The name Weimar Republic was never used officially during its existence. Despite its political form, the new republic was still known as Deutsches Reich in German, rendered in a literal translation as German Empire but often called German Reich in English, due to confusion over the use of the term "empire" for a republic which had given up imperial ambitions and due to the word "reich" having other possible non-imperial translations.[2] The common short form remained Germany. The term reich would regain its use as a term describing empire when the Nazis used it.

Weimar Republic is what I refer to before the Rise Of Nazi Germany before Hitler was made Chancellor. So pardon me for referring it as Nazi, Err Pre-Nazi is perhaps the better term, however at the same time Nazi's had political positions in the Weimar Republic where Nazism was constructive in making a better Germany after WWI.

It seems that threadstarter is just an ignoramus one. No education, no knowledge, no mind. It could be excusable for a 10 y/o kid, but not for 22 y/o man IMHO :disgust

That's very bad for you. I'd suggest you to read some good books instead of getting your knowledge from Wikipedia. :helpme

So you're saying that you know more about it than creators of documentary mentioned above? Come on then, russian rat boy, enlighten us.

Let me see if I got this right. Stalin let a Ukrainian "nazi" walk into his office and then talk him into starving millions of the Ukranian's fellow citizens to death.

Hitler's been blamed for a lot of things, and rightly so, but I think this one just might be a bit of a stretch :1orglaugh

You realize, of course, that Hitler didn't even come to power until a full year after the Ukrainian famine began.

To "us"??? I thought you are the only one here who learned the world's history from wikipedia. What a shame for your parents and former school teachers! :disgust

Nope, when I said "Ukrainian Nazi", I meant Ukrainian nationalist - there is nothing common with German Nazi, Hitler etc.

Come on, russian prick, don't change the subject. Who is responsible for 7m Ukrainians starved to death? Soviets, no?

Yeah and these documentarys are a really bad way of getting knowledge, American directors on movies about Soviet union or political things are going to be totally biased and twisted.

Like how in Hollywood movies Arabs and Russians are ALWAYS the bad guys, and the good ol precious American is the hero.

Btw - Wikipedia is a really bad source, Universities do not accept it as a source because it is unreliable and can be edited by people who have an agenda.

Here is some statistics about it. 1552 thousands Ukrainians and 85 thousands Russians, 27 thousands Jews, 21 thousands Poles еtс have died on Ukraine in 1933 during "golodomor".

Now about your first question. The name of a person who signed the grain procurements decree was Vlas Chubar'. He was Ukrainian (not Russian, not Jewish, not American). Once again he was Ukrainian. Furthermore, he was known as a very nationalistic Ukrainian leader.

So just shout the fuck up and don't try to discuss something you know nothing about. Quit with wikipedia and comics. Learn history as it was suggested to you here a few times already.

Vlas Chubar was a Soviet politician, you idiot.

One thing that people need to understand about the crimes of the Soviets (which are horrific in scale) is that millions of Russians suffered and died along with the Ukrainians, Chechens, Latvians etc. It is not accurate to place the blame for all the atrocities on the Russian people.

Leninist/Marxist ideology was an intellectual sickness which afflicted many different groups and cultures. The Russians themselves are no more culpable then the Western intellectuals who subsidized and supported Lenin and Stalin's crimes against humanity. For the most part Russians were victims just like everyone else of a dedicated minority of madmen who were cheered on by the western leftists and intellectual sitting in cafés in New York and Paris.

Lenin and Stalin's crimes would not have been possible without active support and a dedicated propaganda effort from European and American leftists. They have the same blood on their hands as any Chekist...... they just did their dirty work form the safety of the "decadent" West.

If you doubt my point just think about this....... how many times have you seen some useful idiot wearing a t-shirt with the face of the notorious Marxist mass murderer Che Guevara? Before people go blaming the Russians they might want to take a look at themselves.

In your first post you are talking about Russian politicians. Aren't you?

That's why I asked you: who are "they"?

Thanks a lot for a sane explanation. I'm too tired to hear from everywhere that Russians are the only one nation that is responsible for Soviet crimes. Why the ppl can't understand a simple thing: Russian nation is a major victim of Stalin's regime.

No, you didn't ask me, you called me a moron.
Suomi asked:
'who are "they"?'
and I replied:
'The Soviet leaders? People who supported maxism... Lenin, Stalin... Oh come on, I though you were from Russia, shouldn't you know better?'

Read the fucking thread before you post.

Great post.

Ok, here we go:

You quoted another post originally

As you can see I explained who are 'they' long before you made your lame post.


Really, are you stupid or something? Start paying attention or fuck off.

When you consider the millions of ethnic Russian victims of Lenin's Red Terror along with the millions of ethnic Russians needlessly sacrificed by Stalin in the war with Germany and the millions who perished in Stalin's Gulag, then it is safe to say that ethnic Russians were the biggest victims of Leninist/Stalinist terror, brutality and incompetence.

Obviously you didn't read AlienQ's posts (err - wikipedia copy and pastes).

:1orglaugh

Absolutely - by far.