Is there a danger of upsetting members by doing this...?
 

All paysites that I currently have are more general niches (hardcore, tits, lesbo, mature etc.). All these sites are being incorporated into one members area in an attempt to maximise retention (so all members get full access to all content).

Question is...do you risk upsetting the general surfer by placing more extreme (less run-of-the-mill) site content in there? (so shemale, throat fucking, ATM, fetish etc.).

Comments would be appreciated. :)

Make a seperate site that incorporates it all, leave the other ones but let members know about the main one.

You mean the more extreme stuff have a standalone members area per site and direct the existing run-of-the-mill members to those areas if they wish to see such stuff?

I have my paysites in one members area - softcore boob - with hardcore big dick - and a mixture of others. No problems at all with members.

If the people aren't into that niche, they simply won't visit the other links. However if they have any interest, they will..

I like the idea of one members area.

Music to my ears...thank you.

Any other thoughts? Is there an argument which says don`t show one niche to a set of members which is the totally opposite to what they joined for?

I think you may upset a very small percentage of your members, but you are giving them more content to view, which should increase your membership retention rate.

Biggest issue is flipping it over - everyone that had a saved browser pw and can't remember it, will now contact support :)