Audi vs BMW vs Acura
 

I know the GFY crowd has tons of advice when it comes to cars. I've suddenly found myself in need of a new car (nothing like a broken clutch for the holidays) I've been looking at the Audi S4 for a little while, but the BMW 3 series and Acura TL are in the same price range, so I'm considering them all.

Anybody have any experience with the new Audi S4 (or A4), BMW 328 or 335, or the Acura TL? Anything is helpful .. have to make a decision ASAP :)

Depends what you want out of a car, each offers a slightly different driver's experience. The S4 or A4 are great if you have a need for AWD, but remember understeer is a factor if you're an aggressive driver. The BMW is a well rounded car and I believe available AWD on some models? The 335 is pimp. Not a big Honda fan, so I have nothing to say on the Acura.

the audi has come along was, but the new 3 series is off the hook...but the acura is your best value

Mr. Romance

Read what Consumer Reports says about the TL.

I love the look of the Audi body, if you live in Europe with winding roads you will love the grip of the quattro on the S4 or if you live in a snow region. The BMW has a heavy steering wheel, I just don't like how the 3 series feels.

Well .. I live in flat sunny Florida, so the all wheel drive isn't such an important option here. I have been driving a sports car for the past 5 years .. so handling and power are nice.

There's just too many bimmers in florida, I'd still go with the S4. Keep in mind though, it loses a lot of value. But it's a much more fun car to drive.

Then compare the 335 to the TL in consumer reports and by test drives. If you want to spend more, Audi can tip the scale in performance, but the A4 and S4 are very lacking. At least in my experience and what I demand from a "performance" car.

Get the Acura - it will last forever :)

There are some excellent deals on E46 M3's that are coming in off lease now.
I was at our local dealership a few weeks ago and they had 4 of them on the lot.Mileage was low,they offer the additional warranty and the prices were all in the low-mid 30's.
Bmws depreciate too.I traded my 03' M3smg in last summer on a new 06 E55amg which stickered at nearly 100k.The M3 cost me 61k when I bought it new,and I got 34k on trade.And my M3 was superclean and low mileage.

Audi all the way

I would go with the Audi.

Plus they have a real sweet end of the year lease deals going on.

I miss you .. I hope you're well.

I learned to drive on an acura .. but I haven't been in one in over 10 years, the consumers report review sounds really good for the acura.

Doing great, Erica - thanks :) In the process of learning to knit, reading A LOT, traveling, still in school, playing with real estate and will eventually have a "fun only" (no ads but if you have biz, you can still push it in msgs) board open. I have you on ICQ and will send you the URL when it's up and running :)

And I stubbed my toe - can I get some cookies? :thumbsup

Happy Holidays and let us know what you get - WITH PICTURES!!

I vote Audi, you gotta love that Quattro.

I have owned 3 bmws, and I just bought an Audi A4. I love both cars, but I still prefer a nice bmw. better road stance and performance.

I love the Audi tho!

Audi ;);)

acura is a honda honda builds the greatest engines in the world (quality wise)
if your leasing get the one that you think has the coolest shit if your buying get a the acura lasts forever higest resale

I would go with the Acura

You live in South Fla.....no need for Quattro - get a convirtble bimmer :)


case solved.

I'm glad you started this thread, I"m thinking about the same cars!!!

p.s. Happy holidays Erica!!! :)

Come on.... This thread needs pics!!

:)

audi!!!

my fiance has an s8 and i think he loves it more than he loves me! :)

he also used to have another audi, but i'm not sure which one. anyways.. he cannot say enough good things about audi!

yes valuable thread...what about prices for getting the car fixed...which is better priced?
I assume bmw costs more for parts

audi hands down

of those 3 I'd take an S4 any day.

Audi S4 (or A4)

i would vote the 335.. looks sweet!

I'd go for 335 in your shoes =)

FWIW, I've owned all three brands and the BMW has been my hands down favorite

My personal experiences...

2001 Acura RL: value and reliability
2003 Audi A6: comfortable but a performance dog
2006 BMW 530: comfortable plus performance and handling unrivaled.