Brady or Manning? Who is better.
 

I take Brady.

And I am taking New England this week. :thumbsup

Brady

678

eli manning + peyton manning = better than brady
otherwise id pick brady

manning :2 cents:

bronco fan :(

brady all the way

GO PATS

brady not the lady

brady until manning gets a title

Brady has the 3 rings on his hand.

Manning has the reputation for choking in big games.


Brady is the best QB of his time, probably better than Joe Montana. Think about all the weapons # 16 had Rice and many other weapons. Brady does it without any superstars.

Manning is a has been..Brady all the way

MIKE VICK FTW
i love him
untuchable

Manning.

Too tough to call one better than the other. All that matters is that Brady has 3 rings and Manning has 0.

Well, let's not go mental. :D

never but heres

my pick
http://cache.boston.com/bonzai-fba/O...99726_3776.jpg

Brady all the way

brady, mannings to busy worrying about commercials and stats, brady was prepping for indy 45 minutes after he bitchslapped minn. Manning was no doubt on the phone with his agent setting up his next boring assed commercial after last weeks game

All things being equal....Brady.

Holy shit you are all on crack.

Brady has one of the best coaches in the league, and some of the best talent around him.

Manning will go down as the greatest qb to EVER play the game. He has been playing with one of the worst defenses except for last year. Has had more than one coach, and has had mediocre talent except for Harrison around him. Shit for years he has had to put up 40 pts just to keep the game close. Plus he calls his own plays, does Brady? I think not.

Brady is good, but not even on the same page as Manning.

IMO Brady is the most over rated QB ever to play the game. Can he be clutch? Sure. Is he good? Yeah. Is he everything he is made out to be? Hell no. Here is why.

1. The first Superbowl he wins he doesn't get there without Drew Bledsoe. He got hurt against the Steelers and Drew came in and saved the day. up until he he got hurt he was not playing that great.

2. Another Superbowl was given to them by a shitty call on a strange rule. He gets hit by the Raiders Woodson and fumbles, but they call it a tuck or some shit like that and he gets a second chance. If they call it what it was, a fumble, the game is over and he goes home. But the crappy call let them keep the ball and Vinitari kicked the winning field goal.

3. The Pats play in one of the weakest divisions in the NFL. There have been a few years that they wouldn't have made the playoffs if they were in a stronger division.

4. He himself hasn't won shit. Two of those Superbowl wins came on clutch kicks by Vinitari. Sure, Brady marched them 30-40 yards to get them into field goal range, but half the QBs in the league could have done that.

He is good, very good but I'm getting sick and tired of hearing just how great he is. He couldn't carry Joe Montana's shoes to the field.

To me Manning is the much better QB. He wins games on a team that often has a bad defense and forces him to score a lot of points. Sure he hasn't won a Superbowl yet, but I think he will one of these days. Winning the Superbowl has a lot less to do with the QB than it has to do with the team as a whole. Look at the Bucs and the Ravens. They had average QBs and offenses that were pretty crappy and they both won Superbowls.

Brady... Go Pats!

Actually if any of you had any common sense, you'd see that not only are these two quarterbacks going to become the best ever, but Manning has pretty much shattered every QB record out there. He IS the better quarterback, but he DID choke in big games. Then again if any of you saw the Denver game last week, you could see that his choking days are over. I would take him over Brady any day, and that is why his team is always the best every year.

Peyton has had hall of fame skill players around him the bulk of his career. Brady has not. They are both great QBs. But SB Rings > Stats, so for now Brady is the best.

Dude, you can't say his choking days are over because he beat Denver in the regular season. He's always been superman in the regular season. He needs to prove himself in the playoffs. A QB is ultimately judged by rings and not stats. Otherwise, Dan Marino would be considered the greatest QB of all time and not Montana.

BTW, Vanderjaght fucked Peyton last year or he might have gotten one.

bunch of cock sucking faggots in this thread.

manning is twice the QB brady is. im sorry but when you slang for 50 TD's in a season its hard for me to sway to a chump who has never even reached 30 in his career.

not to mention manning has never had a defense that could even compare to any of brady's defenses since hes been in the league. its kind of hard to win big games when you have to put up 35 points every game with less time of possesion then the other team. all because your defense can't keep them off the field and out of the endzone.

that was the first year he won the championship. most controversial call ever in the history of football ESPN said so. if al davis (owner of the raiders) would quit sueing the NFL he might actually get some calls to go his way.

if they lose that game hes a 2nd string chump today. amazing the way things work out.

Peyton Manning is the better player. :pimp

This game is hard to pick today. I usually like to take the home team in close games and with the Colts having a tuff game last week in Denver it points more towards the pats for me. But I'm still trying to decide.

Brady.. cause he has the rings

So does Trent Dilfer:321GFY

Manning has the better stats, but until manning can win where it really counts.. (A championship) people will only remember him as the best QB of all time, with a asterisk beside his name.

Manning had Harrison, Wayne, James and one of the best offensive lines in football.

Brady has marginal WRs, and before they signed Dillon, a marginal tailback.


Manning is a choke artist. Brady is a winner.

Payton fool

His choking days are over because he beat Denver? lol. BTW he chokes in the playoffs not regular season moron. Now who's lacking common sense?

Brady, and the Colts lose this time. Manning has way better weapons. Brady plays the position as well and presice as it can be played. Reminds me of Montana.

AFC will come down to NE and Denver.

uh the idiot that obviously doesn't 'get it'. I've never seen him as consistent as this year. He ALWAYS makes the big plays. And the idiots that say the Colts have a better defense, wake the fuck up. Their defense against the rush is one of the worst in the league, if not the worst. I saw that Denver game, everytime the other team scored, Manning led a drive for another touchdown. And guess what, unlike Brady or anybody else in the league, Payton calls plays without a huddle, without the coaches assistance. He pretty much runs the game and is a master of it. Lets see brady doing that, please. Anyways the line is Patriots -3 I think, but I still have to go with the Colts.

I hate all Mannings.


Brady has the talent and experience to win this game. Pats are a tight and very professional team. I picked New England across the board this week.

Brady wins. Period. He can lead his team in the last quarter when behind like no one else.

Brady has never had great receivers or even running backs until recently.

Manning has had James, Harrison, Wayne, and others in previous years. :2 cents:

Have you not being paying attention to his career?

And look at who they have played so far. Nothing to brag about yet.

Saddam wins!!!!!


Oh wait no he doesnt...

manning will prob hold every passing record when he retires, that being said, most people would say that u have to win the big game to be regarded as the "best qb ever"

ditto

:( :(

Yes I have. Every year he's getting better and better. His team has been the best team for years. Yes he DOES choke in the playoffs but I believe we will see differently this year.

just like last last year, and the year before, and the year before, and the year before, and the ye... yeah you get it.. and next year will be his year too, and the year after, and the year after, and the yea... yeah, you get it.

Manning is a talent, but I think he runs the team, when the coach should run the team. He calls plays that benefit him, it excites the crowd, and he is talented enough to pull them off.

But if you want to win titles, you have to give up the big numbers and spread things out....

Go Indy!

Brady ofcourse.

Ok, you have a team with the worst record in the league. You have the first pick in the draft. Who ya gonna pick Brady or Manning?

You could plug Manning into any offense and he would shine. Brady is a product of a system, just like Montana. Look how bad Montana sucked when he went to KC.

Brady, Bledsoe was sucking ass in the "system", insert 3rd string qb = superbowl.