McPhee or Hicks?
 

Who wins?

Katherine McPhee has the better voice but she hits some sharp notes sometimes. Is this the best singer we have America?

I already started this thread about 15 minutes ago.........

Hicks - just becuase i think his last name is cool

Taylor. Taylor. Taylor.

soul patrol

Hicks is just an average singer at best. He's like Adam Sandler in the Wedding Singer. I think two of the worst singers made it to the final this year.

I think McPhee should have sung every song standing still and bouncing up and down. Slam dunk! lmao.

But I think Hicks should take it, then again they can overrule any vote as much as they want, so it's kinda pointless really.

Taylor Hicks... not because he's better but because he's more genuine, and more mainstream.

:1orglaugh :1orglaugh

McPhee is better to look at but from the begining I have liked Hicks!
He has a rustic voice and he knows how to get down and let loose.
He got my vote.
:)

she is kinda hot

Yeah! She's got a great "girl next door" look to her.
She'd make great content eh. "McPheedMeCock.com"

hehe