a Program/Site that makes 2 Gifs into a button?
 

I had the site bookmarked, but I lost it...the site would let you submit your own images and then it would make it into a button for you (so the image would act like a button, when you press it, it would go down)

Anyone know of a similar free site? or can you do that in imageready or photoshop?

photoshop, right IR has an animation window

just pay for it.