Need help buying a diamond....
 

I was checking around and the big thing seems to be clarity and color. A shit color, with huge flaws that I can't see is half as much as a "better" diamond. Any reason in hell to pay the extra?

Depends, u gonna wear it or u gonna give it to some girl? if its one of the 2 buy the cheaper one :Graucho

you can see even the smallest flaw if you look closely. Clarity same thing.

Neither my friend nor I could see the flaw. Very busy cut. The normal round one or "princess cut"

It is for a girl. Best case she dies it. Worst case we fight over it in divorce court and I lose it as a gift anyways.

Diamonds are for suckers. It's a terrible investment at the retail level, and it's merely a symbolic rock. Most women are so clueless that you can buy them zircon copies and they won't even notice the difference.

Because you dont want a shit diamond, resell value, and you know your girl is gonna take that shit to a jeweler to find out how much it cost