Eric? Theo?
 

... but I really think GFY needs one set of those "like/dislike" buttons for posts

else, I'll cry until you do it :Oh crap

We kind of tried that with the popularity things and it didn't work well if I recall.

it's not the same at all. A rating system doesn't equal rep, rating systems are for posts, rep is for users :2 cents:

agree completely :thumbsup

rep was stupid... that one 'rep generator' thread that that one meathead created gave all the trolls like insane amounts of rep.. never seen a mess like that on any other board i have been on. I guess adult is a different crowd hehe

- Epic Theo help gif goes here -

That's putting it rather mildly :1orglaugh

The popularity thing was hilarious.

Baddog and some others giving bad rep to people, who in turn would cry all day about getting bad rep from someone. You'd think that reputation on GFY (or any web forum) had some direct impact on their lives the way they screamed.

I think GFY should bring it back.

:thumbsup

The rep thing was fun, but a like button would show a lot more traffic I would bet.

I cant live if you dont say how top notch i am :upsidedow

The problem with rep was that only the people with big post counts could give it and so they could share the good rep amongst themselves and neg rep those with low post counts.

A rep system for the buy and sell section where you could rep people you have done business with would be useful.

Harvey FTWW!!

No button for you!

yes no requests.

Gfy is broken?

Slashdot has a pretty good system to +1 or -1 posts. Active members are randomly chosen every few hours to be able + or - posts, so noone can do much damage.

Words are so much better than buttons.

Some forums also had ability how you cant give negative rep without losing your own positive score.

and i think it's all nonsense anyways

Bring back rep!

Yeah , but Harvey wants it:helpme

"like/dislike" feature will make me feel like I am in Social Network

A troll button would be nice :)

Say if a user gets 100 troll votes he gets a "Badge" to his account. 200 votes he gets supertroll status :D

I would LIKE this thread.

So would Eric
http://www.fubarwebmasters.com/galle...735/z04509.jpg

Which is enough reason NOT to add it... :2 cents:

hataz...

anyway, here's my proposal in a graphic way so even GFY users can understand it :winkwink:

includes code at the side

http://mozlo.com/gfy/thumbs-up-smiley.jpg :melikey:
http://mozlo.com/gfy/thumbsdown.png :fuckoff:
http://mozlo.com/gfy/facepalm.gif :paulmarkham:

fuckoff should have a middle finger man, NOT thumbs down..and a pissed off face, NOT a sad face..lol

I've never "liked" anything online before. A GFY post would get my like cherry probably.

;melikey:

http://static.microcosmpublishing.co...image_1898.gif

Yes, true.

I don't understand why they wouldn't have put this in already. Even if someone tries to game it, it would likely be obvious by all their positive rep coming from new/mostly unused accounts.