American Horror Story theories, explanations, etc (will probably contain spoilers)
 

I may have missed it, but why is Tate the Rubber Man? Quinto(Sylar, Spock) is the one who bought the outfit, but when he was killed in an earlier episode he seemed surprised that it was even there.

Why is Tate responsible for killing people that live in the house?

Do you think the daughter is now dead and did, in fact, succeed at her suicide attempt? She hasn't left the house in a while.

Was there any point to the guy afraid of urban legends aside from letting us know that 'shit happens'?

The dentist sure didn't seem all that freaked out by the appearance of the doctor and went along with his plan. Did we really need the Black Dahlia to have been murdered at the house? How many more characters can they possibly introduce?

Will Jessica Lange's boytoy come back even tho his body isn't buried or still on site at the house? Most of the former residents' bodies should be there either including Tate, the gay couple and whatever remains of burn victim guy's family, but yet the made thinks she can leave if her body is discovered.

A lot of things don't make a whole lot of sense to me at this point. I'd love to hear other thoughts and questions anyone else might have.

My Question?

Why was episode 5, so completely shit, compared to the first 4??

Which one was episode 5?

Halloween part 2

EDIT: In the UK, 5 is the most recent episode... Loved the 1st 4, but 5 was shit... IMO

I did say this thread would probably contain spoilers.

I am not complaining... A lot of stuff you said, means nothing to me anyway... However, it IS half 3 in the morning for me... So I'm off to bed ! Night Night :)

I guess this ep is showing how the timeline works.

Why did the maid age after she died?

I really got tired of that show recently, it doesn't seem to make any sense even when you think you get the point they make it more confusing and weird. FX should stick to sex and action, not this mystery junk

I fucking knew it! I called it weeks ago that Violet was dead.

I thought this show started out great, but its become a giant mess. Ghosts that have sex with and can kill people, and they go on living visible to anyone. People getting killed every week and the family goes on living in the house. Too many new ghost characters popping up from week to week, the backstories, the baby, etc. It's just way too much too soon and its all getting confusing and fucking ridiculous -- just like Nip/Tuck was, and too a certain extent, Glee. Both shows by the same creator.

I tried watching Glee for 5 minutes and didn't care for it.

Nip/Tuck certainly turned into a complete mess the last season or 3.

Horror Story became a mess about 3 episodes into this season.

what the fuck is everyone talking about?!?!? :helpme

Holy fuck, i just woke up from a nap and have no clue what's going on this episode.

This show totally seems like it went off the rails.

Maybe I'm just drunk but, wtf is going on in this show?

The house is asleep and it's dreaming all that shit ...

There is an island. There are a lot of people that crashed into it. Locke has to push the button. There are others. Wrong show? :uhoh

Gotta watch the show from episode 1, good show, writing got a little iffy on the last few, too many people dead in that place now.... but seems after last episode there's some big reveal coming next week for the finale', what the fuck else could they reveal??

the first few episodes was so damn good it became one of the best shows i´ve ever seen.
but since halloween it started to degrade and now it´s just interesting to see what´s going on there but i don´t feel the excitement like from episode 1.

This makes me want to jerk off now.

EPISODE 12/14/11 SPOILERS - Don't read if you didn't watch it yet.

Vivian gave birth to her twins, one of which was still-born, the other was taken by the "good" ghosts of the house to protect it (so hence the gay guy telling Violet that the baby was safe and he wasn't getting it). In the process, Vivian died, and is now forever to roam the house, but with Violet, who you had correctly predicted was dead, so neither of the two are terribly upset about it.

Shortly before the birth, Ben realized that the house is haunted, and that he is in fact seeing ghosts, which led him to a near breakdown during Vivian's labor. The gay guy (I can't for the life of me remember his name), woke Violet up to the fact that Tate is pure evil. That is why Tate is the Rubberman: he's pure evil and will constantly murder, rape, etc. Tate for some reason is supressing memories, and is in denial about whether he's evil or not.

I think that's everything that went down last night. I think the show is still as amazing as ever, but there is a lot of shit going on, so it is more crucial than ever to pay attention to every second of the show.

As far as next week's season finale, it was hinted that Ben kills himself, as well as finds out some shocking information about the house and everything that goes on in it. I'm torn on whether he will actually kill himself. I can kind of see him as a living character next season, who lurks and observes, sort of like the guy that was half burnt did before he went to jail. I'm not sure how much he'll openly interact with the new home occupants, but I think he'll definitely do whatever it takes to protect his family that is now trapped in the house.

Here:

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_ls...zwvdo2_500.gif

http://26.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_ls...zwvdo4_400.gif

http://27.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lt...qd52o1_400.gif

http://29.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lt...2o8_r2_400.gif


:thumbsup

:1orglaugh:1orglaugh:1orglaugh

Izzy, do not rehash our discussions from 5 or 6 years ago.

Didn't the show start at the end? The wife trying to stab/slash her husband?

According to the psychic tate didn't actually know he was dead, but seems he does have a memory of being killed by the cops. yet... somehow... doesn't remember anything he did leading up to it.

How is the real estate agent involved? I'm sure she could concentrate on other properties and i KNOW there'd be someone who would buy that house with that history. If I had the money I know I would.

There's just a shitload of things that don't make sense.

She was nude in this past season's True Blood. :thumbsup

Next week's episode we will find out that the writers, producers and directors have been dead the whole time.

Uhm, it was already explained in an episode that Tate DID know he was dead.

I have no idea WTF you are talking about.

their going the way of the tv show lost :Oh crap their flashing around people popping in and out of the child birth. :helpme i was thinking someone laced my ice cream :1orglaugh they killed off two of the main characters its way too early too kill people off :2 cents:

When they renewed it for a new season there was already talk of using a different family next season.

One of my favorite shows this season

http://i.imgur.com/wiM0g.gifhttp://i.imgur.com/HfNx3.gif
http://i.imgur.com/vTAIU.gifhttp://i.imgur.com/O47CI.gif
http://i.imgur.com/i1S8C.gif


http://i.imgur.com/rclJP.gifhttp://i.imgur.com/OULAT.gif
http://i.imgur.com/Swojg.gifhttp://i.imgur.com/hO4Ap.gif
http://i.imgur.com/36OZV.gif

http://i.imgur.com/L0xkD.gifhttp://i.imgur.com/hQzcE.gif
http://i.imgur.com/dO3Ce.gifhttp://i.imgur.com/NRTed.gif
http://i.imgur.com/vTgZz.gif

http://i.imgur.com/Shiib.gifhttp://i.imgur.com/oieFu.gif

that's pretty damn bold :2 cents: so its just like their doing a pilot all over again. :helpme if i invested money in this show id be pissed :disgust

:1orglaugh:1orglaugh:1orglaugh


The show is created by one of the guys behind Nip/Tuck and Glee. I don't think the investors are worred. :2 cents:

we'll see glee sucks ass :2 cents:

Totally love this show...and the reason it was renewed for another season..
well, let's just say the house has a few more surprises in store for ya!