Johnny Depp as Freddie Mercury?
 

MTV News reports that Jack Sparrow himself is in talks to play Freddie Mercury in a movie being developed by Robert De Niro?s Tribeca Productions.

Do you think this is a good casting?

discuss

http://www.premiere.cz/img/clanky/2619.jpg

Sure, why not?

ADG Webmaster

yea why not?Depp is a good actor...

absolutely - he's the best choice of any well known star for the job. johnny depp is the best american actor of his generation.

I think he can pull that off.

hes a great actor

he would do a great job

Good choice

There's no better character actor in the world.

I have to agree with who there, from 21 jump street to Edward scissorhands and finally movies like blow and Pirates of the Carribean.... He mastered his rolls in each.

I am not sure he is the ideal casting for the role, but then again what are the options?

They need a top actor for the role, but who else can play Freddy Mercury without looking overacted and fake ?

I love them both :)

As long as he doesn't have to sing, then yeah...

sean penn i believe :)

I say the show must go on.

I can't wait to see this movie :Graucho

:thumbsup

I <3 Johnny. :wetkiss

I dont know.

Im inclined to scream "boooooo!".

If he can pull it off as well as Val Kilmer pulled off Morrison, then i'll regret booing, but i really dont think that johnny depp will do a decent/good job. I really dont think hes that good an actor, and i think more people would agree if they started thinking about the roles he have had.

A drunken pirate?
Didnt really like him as Willy Wonka.
Wasnt very good in the Secret Window/From Hell/Sleepy Hollow roles.
Benny & Joon?

Only roles i kinda liked him in was Gilbert Grape really, and that wasnt a very "difficult" role.

And before casting him to play the greatest modern musical genious, lets try to remember what Johnny did in Crybaby. If that movie hadnt featured Traci Lords and Iggy Pop, i would have shot myself in the face when i watched it.

Not trying to be negative, i just dont think Johnny Depp is that good an actor and i think its obvious when hes given more demanding roles : )

And i think the role of Freddie Mercury deserves a great actor. Im hoping that if they will make the movie they will cast someone 'better' and less known really.

Even though thats the kinda thinking that gave us elijah wood as frodo (someone kill that kid please).

I think he could do it...if Sascha Baron Cohen had any real acting talent he would do a good visual job.

no way... you really think so? for starters, when it comes to character acting, Penn is fairly average. Think Nicholas Cage... technically great actor, bu the same guy no matter what the roll is.

He doesn't look like Mercury but he is a perfect actor . May be it is a good idea.

The same could pretty much be said about Mr Depp.

No, Depp a fantastic character actor. Look at his Jack Sparrow - does he act like that in every role? no :thumbsup

oh... Im looking forward to that movie! Guess lots of gay people does too!

Well yes he does, pretty much :)

I agree its not as bad as Nicholas Cage, but its still true.

Pirates movies, which takes a lot from how he played his "Eccentric Noble" type character.

Sleepy Hollow, Corpse Bride, Charlie & Chocolate Factory, (Secret Window), From Hell, Ninth Gate.

And his "hurt emotional guy" roles. Crybaby, Scissorhands, Chocolat and more according to my girlfriend. I couldnt stand him in those roles, so i stopped watching those type movies :)

In general i think it was hard for him to shake 21 Jump Street.

And in restrospect, you were probably sarcastic in your post so i just made a dufus out of meself :)

what is the problem with that?

As a HUGE Freddy fan, I would have to say NO. I don't think the camparison is strong enough. But, Johnny Depp has a way of making a role his own and really becoming convincing. So.. who knows.

I think he is a great choice for the part

Bummer. I'm sure that you will end up regreating that "boooo" lol. Johnny Depp is one of if not THEE best character acter ever. Also remember such films as "Ed Wood" etc. I can understand that it is your opinion and that you only enjoyed him in a couple of flicks, where I on the other hand have enjoyed every single Depp movie and thought that he was fantastic.

I disagree with you on the "Cry Baby" flick. That was an awesome movie, with or without Tracy Lords and Iggy...come on..."Hatchet Face?" LOL

I personally think that Depp will be able to pull off this character better than anyone else out there. But again, that is my opionion and I am glad to see that others share that with me :)

I LOVES me some Johnny Depp :P

PS Benny and Joon was an amazing movie...IMO!

Do you think he'll have to do a gay gangbang scene?

Will he wear false giant teeth?

hes the most beautifull actor of present

Jesus Christ dude... between Depp and DeCaprio, they are the best actors of their generation.

Who is a good actor to you? Adam Sandler? :1orglaugh

i could see that

yea, as long as he has a huge stache, he can pass as Freddy.

Hahah yeah right, have you ever seen Freddy in a gay gangbang scene? LOL

And I would imagine he'll be bringing back out those chompers from "Willie Wonka" :P

lmao
thats funny!
:thumbsup

Very good choice :thumbsup

I have to agree, he is one of the best at becoming his character..Bad Boys, Fast Times as Ridgemont High, Mystic River, Colors, I could go on forever. But this roll fits Depp much better for sure.

He's perfect for the role

It's actualy depend how good is his vocal possibilites.