Contest Finalists - Which Would You Choose?
 

Well the Design A Site For Dawson contest is over - it was run on here and Stan's AdultDesignContest.com site - I was worried at first that I may have pissed away $1500 for a $300 tour but it worked out the way I hoped - got to see various concepts - the winner will come from this group, and i'll probably try to buy another one. Photos will change on some of them - some designers aren't great at photo selection.

(A)

http://www.bratcash.com/dawson/dm_1.jpg

(B)

http://www.bratcash.com/dawson/dm_2.jpg

(C)

http://www.bratcash.com/dawson/dm_3.jpg

(D)

http://www.bratcash.com/dawson/dm_4.jpg

(E)

http://www.bratcash.com/dawson/dm_5.jpg

(F)

http://www.bratcash.com/dawson/dm_6.jpg

(G)

http://www.bratcash.com/dawson/dm_7.jpg

Out of all of them B.

Every other one shows to much and does not understand the concept of tease. Hell most of them you all ready get to see the nipples and the coochie so unless she is hardcore there is no umph to get them in to discover her real personality.

Some are also utterly cheesy, not naming which though out of respect of the work that may have went into them.

BTW I do not care as much about flashy or pretty, I am just thinking overall.

voted!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GFY is screwy - i only posted the poll once -

thanks for voting

its more about the design, not the images showing too much.. Mutt can change the images..

The designer should of thought of that. Plus I know some will have been sliced and whatnot. So to me that is not an excuse.

I don't like most of them. I think C has the most attention-grabbing design, but really crap photos.

:thumbsup! Yumm shake it !!

C looks HOT.

I fucked her. If not, I'll fuck her.

All designs are dull, but my vote goes for C, at least it grabs your attention, I've seen all other before. And many many times, for $1500 you'd expect a little originality

:1orglaugh :1orglaugh :1orglaugh

well, I'm not hung like you, but at least we share the same taste! C all the way :thumbsup

Definately G

The first and the last.

buster has voted

im gonna have to go with B, looks very simple and easy to signup :)

voted!!!!

G :thumbsup

I love the (G)-design but the (E)'s pictures are better I think. they look more innocent.. I'd choose (G) with the pictures from (E)

Just like to confirm if u had seen my entry and just not like it?
I have already made a flash design in it and site has a preview in
http://www.kitti2x.com/portfolios/to.../dawsonmiller/

http://www.kitti2x.com/portfolios/to...w/entry-01.jpg

Just asking hope u dont mind :thumbsup

I like it! :thumbsup good luck

thank u! :winkwink:

Out of all of them, this one stands out and looks amazing :thumbsup

Thanks man! :thumbsup

Damn, hard decision, but i would go with A.

no - don't mind - we did like yours - it's polished and we liked the Flash - i should have posted it here with the others - but there are three here that we had pretty much narrowed it down to - and posted others to see if maybe we missed one - yours is definitely nice, better than some of these. this is why contests suck - there's only one winner and everybody feels their's is the best. i saw the NatNet logo contest - i don't think the best logo won that one and i'm sure lots of people will think i will pick the wrong one too.

Thanks for the response. I appreciate it so much!:winkwink: Good Luck to everyone!

G but with different colours. She is DAMN HOT in that large pic :thumbsup

great entries all around. :thumbsup

and thanks to all who voted for me. i really appreciate it. some really nice, honest people here at this community. thanks again for the opportunity!

Regardless of the opinions posted here, this is a good thread Mutt. Great idea.

G for GOOD

I thought D and F would be getting more votes. The kitti2x one looks nice too, far better than a couple of the selection poll (imho, of course). ie, I still don't see why the hype about G design, it looks more like a long gallery or FPA where you barely see the site name, the join button is almost the same color as the BG and put just in the opposite way you'd put it, ie bottom right or center, that's basic design and marketing. On a multiple selection poll I'd choose C, B, D, A and Kitti2x designs

lesson for designers: if you as a surfer have to look where the fucking join link is hidden, you're doing something wrong :2 cents:

like i told kitti2x - a couple of the designs were posted here and aren't as nice as his/hers(?) because somebody really liked them - the black one Dawson really likes for instance.

very surprised that (D) hasn't got much feedback

(G) has a great element in it - the big photo of her is very cute, it's a perfect photo for a tour splash page - she looks cute, young and she's naked but it's softcore - it's over photoshopped tho, look at her ass - she has no butt crack left haha

I like B, but it appears C is going to win.


On a side note, I jsut saw pics of your new model Jewel... DAMN I cant wait till her site is up, she fits the traffic I have perfect.

thanks dude! by the way matt im a his and thanks for the comment too! Good Luck to everyone! :winkwink:

yay I'm winning so far :)

I hope it continues like that :winkwink: Anyway, both my designs share a concept, and even though C is already doubling in votes the second one, which is very flattering, I see D is 3rd in votes. Both designs combined have more votes than all the remaining together, which I think proves my concept is right: people is ready for unique ideas. I took the "risk", and even tho I was convinced it wasn't a risk at all, it already paid off.

As for changes... well, keep in mind this is a contest. When I do a design, I work close to the customer, we exchange ideas and work on different aspects to get a final result that fits the taste of the customer. In a contest, I work with what I consider will be best. And it's not like I did this kind of designs for the first time, I already made several of them, and they're doing awesome, I remember Biggy posting some stats for a design I did for him, more or less the same style as these tours and he was doing more sales per day than most programs in a month. I'm not bragging nor anything, just trying to put some objectiveness in what may look extremely subjetive.

As for pics selection... well, Mutt knows well, and I'm sure he'll tell what's needed. I've experimented with tease/show and always find out you need to balance. Hence why I chose one pic showing tits, once showing ass and the remaining ones just teasing. This way I think the surfer knows POSITIVELY he'll find her nude. And he'll want to see more of the non nude sets knowing she'll be nude, as opposite to many solo sites where you don't know if she'll be covered and teasing or if she'll give something for the buck. Again, if I win, I'll change any pic if needed. And I guess any of the designers here would do the same :winkwink:

now I'm out to the movies, good luck to everybody

PS: kittis design is nice, and I thought Kaiser's design would be selected as well. You see, everything is in the eye of the beholder

I see Kaiser already has one design in this poll, I mean the other one posted at ADC, it's neat as well :thumbsup

Looks like C won.

F and G are definitely nice but when I saw kitti2x's design, it looks better than the rest. Some guy pointed me to this thread and told me how the contest world works so I'm thinking, what's wrong with this? Is this totally political?

kit2x my freind...great job...you one of the hell designer...