Three inmates die at Guantanamo
 

3 is a start

It is criminal what is happening there.

i concur.

I agree, it is criminal to keep those "inmates" alive

hehe...right. they should've been punished long time ago

.. on what verdict ???

... following what trial ????


- most of the poor fuckers are there because they were at the wrong place at the wrong time ... and because AmeriKa has turned in a racist country ( half of it at least )....

You want guilty ones ??? go to Saudi Arabia, Yemen

Man thats gonna get nasty.

Sorry :offtopic
















Check out the sig :thumbsup

the media doesnt cover everything that happens over there and the US gov certainly contains a lot of incidents that might happen.

its racist to capture enemies on the battlefield?

or is it racist to suggest that suicide bombers are typically arabs who follow islam?

No time to debate for nothing ....

These people were in the vicinity of the so called battlefield ... in Afghanistan, not in NY city ...

But if they are combattants, charge them and proceed with a trial ... After all, you guys are better then Saddam aren't you ?


For race, here is what your good friends did not so long ago :

I'm sure if they would have been Irish name, that raid and shooting would not have happened ... at least now... 10 years ago, sure : Irish were their terrorists ....


Meanwhile, be proud of Guantanamo .. great example :thumbsup

"Three inmates die at Guantanamo" is an incorrect title. "Three prisoners commit suicide" would be more accurate.

i love all the "directfiesta against the usa" rhetoric. where would the world be without you alerting them to all thats wrong?

please show us this utopia where you live. please!? we promise we won't kill any puppies there or make any children cry. we just want to see this place where all is perfect and pretty little butterflies live forever. give us hope. show us this place that is above criticism and has no flaws and can do no wrong. show us the light. guide us to being better people.

i am pretty sure the rate of death for a successful suicide hovers around 100%.

Go figure, Bill O'Reily goes down there for a visit/interviews on Friday and three do themselves in!

I agree. Execute the terrorists already. They're a waste of space.

You are wrong, as usual ...

You can " commit " suicide, but not die .... not successfull ... I am sure you will have a hard time to grasp this...

You die because of a car accident, an illness, a suicide ...

Dead is dead, tough not that sure in the USA ...

It's pathetic that liberals have more sympathy for radical Islamic terrorists than they have for their own countrymen.

The prisoners in Guantanamo were captured on the battlefield fighting for Al Qaeda.

You are the equivalent of a Nazi sympathizer, demanding that we treat the guards at Auschwitz with respect.

if they were, why not follow the geneva convention and give them a trial?

Does the Geneva Convention require immediate trials for each and every enemy soldier captured on the battlefield? I wasn't aware of that. Link?

this is GFY... they wont understand ...

On one side they are combattants, on the others terrorists ... while in reality they probably are just plain old folks ... After all, some have been released without charges ...

But " let's talk bout freedom, let's talk bout dmcracy... "

You just show how stupid you are ....

The Geneva Convention does not require that enemy prisoners of war be put on trial.

Other than that, great point.

Here comes the nazi shit ...

BTW, GUARDS were treated according to the Geneva convention, and most were not charged, because they followed orders ... just like the Americans are never charged in Afghanistan or Iraq .. unless irrefutable proof they acted improperly ...

Now, continue comparing the prisonners in Guantanamo to prison gards ..

Funny, I would have the other way round:

Comparing US troops there to the Nazi guards ... same principle ( race based )...

The geneva convention only applies to uniformed soldiers fighting for a country under a flag and the boys in Gitmo were fighting without uniforms for the Taliban which is not a country !

It also applies to militias, not just guys who happen to be wearing a nice uniform.

The Geneva Convention does NOT require that enemy soldiers/militia members be put on trial.

Other than that, great point.

They are innocent untill proven guilty. God you are a grade A retard.

yup, they do from article 103:
"Judicial investigations relating to a prisoner of war shall be conducted as rapidly as circumstances permit and so that his trial shall take place as soon as possible."

been a few years hasn't it? http://www.unhchr.ch/html/menu3/b/91.htm < if you want to read more about it..

problem is.. when five US soldiers were paraded in front of the iraqi television cameras for instance, mr Rumsfeld immediately complained that "it is against the geneva convention to show photographs of prisoners of war in a manner that is humiliating for them"...

so atleast he knows about the convention...

They have not been allowed to have a fair trial. When 9-11 part 2 happens you will all ask "Why did this happen when we are the popular country USA?"

You have serious emotional problems. Just thought I'd tell you.

Seek help.

Hawkeye believes the Iraq war was to fight Osama Bin Laden and his buddies. An intelligent dicussion regarding any of these topics can be far easily obtained in the monkey section of a local zoo.

Let me know which school you went, so I don't send my kids there...

You went to school, didn't you ... ????

Now, spin....

because they were not fighting for a national army and were classified as "enemy combatants" which does not entitle them to the same protections under the geneva conventions.

sure they are, from article 4:

"2. Members of other militias and members of other volunteer corps, including those of organized resistance movements, belonging to a Party to the conflict and operating in or outside their own territory,"

so they are prisoners of war and protected by the convention..

I wonder what hawkspastic is like. I bet it is some high school drop out who still has problems wanking.

I was actully agreeing with what you said and had some repect for you until i got to your last sentence, your just a kid.

you asked for the answer... i gave you the answer. i did not say it was the right answer in everyones eyes. don't be an idiot thinking that a simple troll on gfy has all the answers to complex legal questions that governments have massive teams of legal people working on.

D'uh.

Die = how did they die? Dying is not a deliberate act.

Suicide = tells us how they died. Suicide is a deliberate act.