Should Matt Cooper and Judith Miller go to jail?

[mardigras]

http://www.sierratimes.com/rss/newsw...217610&feed=us

http://www.dfw.com/mld/dfw/news/nation/12033054.htm

http://www.theledger.com/apps/pbcs.d...YT02/507010432

Time Magazine has decided to turn over all of Matt Coopers notes to the government, but experts say that may not keep him from going to jail next week.

The case represents the starkest confrontation between the press and the government since 1971, when the Supreme Court refused to stop The Times and The Washington Post from publishing a classified history of the Vietnam War known as the Pentagon Papers. And legal experts said yesterday that they knew of no other instance in modern journalistic history in which a major news organization announced that it would disclose the identities of its confidential sources in response to a government subpoena.

The press has traditionally argued that it needs to be able to protect confidential sources to ensure that the public is fully informed. Some courts have recently rejected that position outright. Other have said that the interest in the flow of information to the public in given cases was outweighed by the needs of the judicial system for evidence.

On Wednesday, Judge Thomas F. Hogan of Federal District Court in Washington said he would order the reporters jailed for up to 120 days if they did not agree to testify before the grand jury in the meantime. He also said he would impose substantial fines on the magazine.

The magazine made its decision over the objections of its reporter.

"For almost two years," Mr. Cooper said yesterday, "I've protected my confidential sources even under the threat of jail. So while I understand Time's decision to turn over papers that identify my sources, I'm obviously disappointed by what they chose."

Time's decision yesterday to turn over documents in the face of fines troubled some legal experts.

"It makes it appear that they did it for the money," said Jane Kirtley, who teaches media ethics and law at the University of Minnesota. "If judges can get these news organizations by the balance sheet, they're going to yield. For Time Warner not to rally round the crown jewel of their empire to support a journalist is appalling."

[High Plains Drifter]

[uno]

It's disgusting. And the guy who started it all. Novak. No charges, nothing. I hope he rots in hell. This country upsets me more and more every single day and most people don't seem to mind its rapid descent.