One of my favoites movies of 2004 so far.
I liked both versions, but preferred the Theaterical version a bit more

I think Aston Kutcher did an admiralble job pullling off drama and I really liked Elden Henson as well and of course, you can never go wrong with Amy Smart...

Saw the theatrical version, but not the director's cut. Any big difference?

I haven't seen it yet so that's good to know

:eek7 :eek7 :eek7

We watched the director's cut but no matter how you slice the ending, the entire movie was a stupid piece of shit. :2 cents:

I may not have had such a harsh opinion if I hadn't heard EVERYBODY giving it rave reviews as though it's a fucking cinema classic when it's mediocre at best. I can't believe people think it redeems Ashton's total lack of talent. Blech.

Now SPIDERMAN 2 . . . THERE'S an entertaining movie worth watching!! The opening credits alone were enough to knock my socks off. :thumbsup

They add in one little piece about the mother having 2 stillbirths before him and at the end the baby ends up killing himself while being born.

Sorry if someone read the spoiler, you should know better... :glugglug

Noooooo!! Noooooooooooooooooooooo!! Not you too!! :waaaaahh

I'm devastated. Favorites of 2004 so far? It's no Showgirls!

The version where he kills himself in his mothers belly. What version is that?

Directors Cut

other than the ending, theres no difference? I rented it the other day and decided towatch the directors cut since i already saw the theater version, but stopped it a little after they blow up the mailbox

We rented that on DVD last night, both enjoyed the experience quite a bit. As good as we expected from the previews and that rarely happens for us much anymore.

There are a few other small differences between the theatrical release and the director's cut. Mostly extra scenes that were added to the director's cut. A couple that stick out in my head is a tiny thing of Ashton getting raped in the jail, the mother explaining she had 2 other stillborn babies before Ashton, an extra scene of the youngest Ashton in school, and a few others that I can't think of at the moment.

Ashton getting raped in jail? Somehow I don't believe that one.

That little kid burned the dog alive :Graucho

yeah it rocks. I watched the directors cut a few nights ago. Wicked movie