It would be really suspicious if they sent the body back missing the head.

Did anyone see coffin pics of him??

That'd be kind of an easy stunt to pull on the family. If you've ever seen a dead body at a viewing they don't usually resemble the loved one very much after all the embalming fluid and makeup is put on them.

:1orglaugh

I haven't seen any pics of him in the coffin, and doubt that there are going to be any. If it ever comes out that the body was sent back minus the head, and the family didn't request a fingerprint analysis, I'd be very very surprised. They've been critically outspoken on other things, so if their son came back headless, I'm thinking we will probably hear about it somehow.

Al Qaida has come out to claim the video is a fraud, but more specifically, has the al-Zarqawi group in question, who claimed responsiblity for the video come out to independantly dispute their involvement?

Agreed Gman.357 'except' this wasn't just a clean cut beheading. This was more of a lengthy 'slicing/sawing'. Just one freakin artery there'ld be blood all over the place, aerosols and strong bursts, gasses and fat and all kinds of junk.

If it wasn't for the bad and odd editing pattern I wouldn't even entertain all this debate.

hehe :1orglaugh

could be...

http://drudgereport.com/flash1.htm

Drudge report says 4 are being held in regard to the murder. Let's see what apple shakes from this tree.

Terrorists dont wear bullet proof vests , they think to die in battle you go right to heaven . If this was your thought why wear something to prevent it . Their hands are very pale looking for middle eastern people. Also the video quality is terrible very unclear and isnt it funny this happened the exact time the government was really starting to feel pressure from what was happening at that prison. The press better wake the fuck up, thats why we have the first amendment the press is supposed to keep the government in check.

I personally think the guy is dead.. why on earth would they keep him alive if indeed it was a fake..Did the CIA do it, I dunno. Did radical Muslim extremist do it.. more than likely.. But who really knows.

I honestly can't make a very good guess as I decided not to watch the video. However the post I copied from the other board brings up some very valid points and just more doubt to what was already very sketchy. Again I didn't watch it, but did the guy struggle at all while his head was getting cut off? I mean from the smalls parts of the video that I've seen (the beginning with the talking). It seems strange if this guy did indeed understand Arabic why didn't he fight at all? Is the gold ring thing true?

Wouldn't really surprise me ... the quality realllly sucks

possible...

I think there is alot more to come out from this storie

The biggest piece of evidence that the video WAS NOT shot in that prison is the floors.

The Floors are completely different. Your not going to get two different kinds of floors in a governent built prision.


Next:2 cents:

or the floor has a mat on it,,,,,,, hmmmmmm

Surely very weird.

I did not like it fake or not...

I haven't watched the vid yet and I don't think I will.

I don't understand how some of you can watch it over and over lookin for evidence and the floor matching and such....ick.

Two cameras were used with different time code (and for different angles) then it was spliced together later.

I own over 50 of those white chairs,,,so I must have been involved,,,right?

I dont know about the scream , He can scream initially , and the rest is the guys around him. But what occured to me when I watched it is the lack of blood. Not being knowledgable enough, but shouldnt there be spurting of blood from the main artery in your neck?? Also when they show the severed head there is no blood dripping. Still I am not going to watch it again for analisys , because I found it disturbing.

really glad *i* didn't post in this thread, don't want the C1A asking me questions when they make it here to squelch this discussion.

uh-oh.. http://twash.com/iku/sweatin.gif

The gold ring thing IS true, but it's also true that Muslim men are not supposed to wear silk and a lot of rich Arabs wear silk robes.

I also read an article that talked about an Arabic translator saying that the accent is all wrong. It sounds nothing like someone from Jordan.

Fishy, but the U.S. having him killed is a stretch.