i'd smack clay, he looks gay

. "I think you're the bastard child of Steve Kmetko and Leeza Gibbons"

hahaha.. Guess the writer of that article did not know that Steve Kmetko is gay..

Luther had a stroke-
not a smoker, alhough some say he prefers to smoke the pole"
It's too bad... I am a huge Luther fan...seen him 3 times once was in '87-

he was trying to sweat his weight off and in the middle of July in a theatre in the round setting at the now defunct Front Row Theatre, in mayfield Village OH, NO AIR CONDITIONING was turned on...

Now I can handle a lot of things but a Luther show in the summer with no AC? Sold out nothing but brotha's and sistah's in the house and me by myself with my radio VIP pass sweating like Al Gore on election day....

I'l never forget the smell of afroshine and sweat...it was like the SOUL GLO Commercial in Eddie Murphy's coming to America
But like a scratch and sniff version...it was 1987 and that wet look was all the rage.

and Ruben is the MOST TALENTED. PERIOD.

Clay is way to elfin- like and androgynous

He'd be great on Broadway and I see him there in a Technicolor Dreamcoat!

There was a girl that graduated from my daughters' school last year that tried out this season for american idol.. She is just as good as Kelly Clarkson if not better , alot thinnner and better looking. She was told " we don't want another kelly Clarkson" . She told them " I AM not Kelly Clarkson ". She was cut..


dumb asses...

I was kinda surprised to see Ruben in the bottom 2 this week as well because he does have a great voice - but he (like Josh) only have 1 sound

Josh is a country singer and Ruben is another Luther and in their market they'll do well.

I think Clay is going to win - he has a great voice and the most marketable of the group.

As far as Josh not being a real marine - that's just silly!

The Marine Corps couldn't buy the kind of recruitment avertising Josh is giving them !

I'm sorry Ruben! I'll never not vote again, I learned my lesson this week.

Brad

Brad, you're so right on. Everyone I've talked to thinks Ruben is gonna sail right into the top two now just because everyone was so freaked when he almost got cut that we'll all vote for him...

I had a scary "Tamyra" moment though, I was so mad when she got cut last year! It should have been her and Kelly in the top 2 last year, not stupid 'Sideshow Justin' hehe

Clay is not made for the pop charts but he can clean up in Vegas and on Adult Contemporary radio forever. I think it's funny that the final group is total geeks and misfits. They want to find the next Britney and instead are finding the next country, musical theater, barry white or chubby girl singer. Funny.

Colon puncher....LMAO...you should trademark that shit.

50! And that show sucks ass!! I can not STAND it!!

this thread is gay

Ugh. I hate that fucking Clay kid. He looks like Martin Short doing a parody of the gay boy banders.

Clay is the next Frank Sinatra
Same sulky voice
Same ugly look
No rythm

He is the shit and I will buy his CD -- He should go to Vegas, He will rake it in

http://www.tapact.com/clay.jpg
http://www.tapact.com/sinatra.jpg

Reuben should wil, that boy can SING, but so can Clay, I just think Reuben is better.

JMHO,
AST

American Idol is a joke. How can you have ANY respect for an 'artist' that can't even write his/her own music and lyrics?

First, Frank Sinatra wasnt a Dork... he was actually the bad boy...

Second... Crooner music was once cool amongs the young...

Clay came too late....


*BTW. is any of the girls here find Clay sexy? (meaning sexually desirable)

I flew out of Atlanta last Saturday and the whole Aiken clan was on the plane. Shirts with Clay's picture and everything. They kind of reminded me of the Beverly Hillbillies on their way to LA. Clay playing the part of Jethro Bodine.

Instead of a truck it was a plane though.