Rant Watching Rogue One A Star Wars Movie

[RyuLion]

First time I heard about this movie, seeing it on Netflix, if you've watched it already, what do you guys think?

[CaptainHowdy]

A film that would nurture the child inside of me ... if it was alive.

[CurrentlySober]

Best star wars movie of recent years ! Lovely beach scenes at the end too

[2MuchMark]

LOVED IT. Saw it in the theatre when it came out last December. Good story, good acting, and a great tie-in to Star Wars: A New Hope.

The only thing I didn't like was CGI Grand Moff Tarkin:



It was very ambitious and seeing it the first time in the theatre worked for me, but after repeated viewings this CG character just became more and more of a distraction. The way he moved sometimes looked like a puppet. And in other scenes, his eyes looked too clear.

But of course I'm knitpicking. The movie was excellent, and the best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy in my opinion.

[The Porn Nerd]

LOVED IT. Saw it in the theatre when it came out last December. Good story, good acting, and a great tie-in to Star Wars: A New Hope.

The only thing I didn't like was CGI Grand Moff Tarkin:



It was very ambitious and seeing it the first time in the theatre worked for me, but after repeated viewings this CG character just became more and more of a distraction. The way he moved sometimes looked like a puppet. And in other scenes, his eyes looked too clear.

But of course I'm knitpicking. The movie was excellent, and the best Star Wars movie since the original trilogy in my opinion.

I would second this. If they had kept Tarkin at a minimum, like they did with Princess Leia, it may have worked. But he was on screen far too much. It reminded me of cut scenes in video games (which can be cool).

Anyway great movie tho some of the supporting characters were not fleshed out enough for my liking (especially the blind guy).

[Bladewire]

It was a great movie loved it! The twist at the end really throws you for a loop!

[RyuLion]

Just finished seeing it, I didn't like that "sad beach" ending. WTF!

[femdomdestiny]

I loved it. Really, got the same feeling as when I was a kid with genuine Star Wars Movies.

[Rochard]

It was a great movie....

[seeandsee]

nasty ending

[TheDynasty]

can't get myself to watch it

[nico-t]

LOVED IT.

Thanks, taking it off of my list of movies to see

[Bladewire]

Thanks, taking it off of my list of movies to see

Pull that swastika out of your ass sourpuss

[Paul&John]

It was awesome! ;)

[C H R I S]

One of the best SW movies.

[nico-t]

Pull that swastika out of your ass sourpuss

[2MuchMark]

Thanks, taking it off of my list of movies to see

What are some of your favourite movies? Maybe we have something in common other than giant penises?

[nico-t]

What are some of your favourite movies? Maybe we have something in common other than giant penises?

how did you know?

some good ones i recently watched:

- life
- hell or high water
- get out

others i really loved:
- big lebowski
- edge of tomorrow
- the matrix
- drive
- terminator 2
- pulp fiction (original right? it's just so damn entertaining)


In case of a match: Wear a red skirt so i know who you are at the airport. I'll wear a red hat.

[EddyTheDog]

how did you know?

some good ones i recently watched:

- life
- hell or high water
- get out

others i really loved:
- big lebowski
- edge of tomorrow
- the matrix
- drive
- terminator 2
- pulp fiction (original right? it's just so damn entertaining)


In case of a match: Wear a red skirt so i know who you are at the airport. I'll wear a red hat.

'Life' was good until the last minute - Who didn't see that coming?..

[RyuLion]

What are some of your favourite movies? Maybe we have something in common other than giant penises?

[just a punk]

First time I heard about this movie, seeing it on Netflix, if you've watched it already, what do you guys think?

A can describe it in a single word: shit

[brassmonkey]

Just finished seeing it, I didn't like that "sad beach" ending. WTF!

they died! sometimes in battle there is no option to make it home. the "planet destroyer" holds up to it's name

[OY]

I give it thumbs up

[RyuLion]

I give it thumbs up

they died! sometimes in battle there is no option to make it home. the "planet destroyer" holds up to it's name

Shhh, no spoilers!!