Any Bank transfer specialists here?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Struggle4Bucks
    Sieg Hi!
    • May 2011
    • 3615

    #1

    Any Bank transfer specialists here?

    I noticed a discepancy between the amount my cc-processor transfers to me weekly
    and the amount that my bank receives. Everytime it's a discepancy of around $4,50,-.

    I do not have to go on foodstamps for this, just trying to understand Banks... which seems
    almost unpossible as an outsider. Everytime i see a bank, my bloodpressure risses and i'm having troubles to not drive my car through the entrance...

    I called my bank (I did a 30 minutes yoga first... or else i would probably start with screaming) and they gave the following explanation:

    My money goes from Bank A in London (i thought i had an American processor) to Bank B in Ney York, because i am paid in dollars and Bank A is in euro area so they need to "buy" dollars so my amount is send to Bank B in Ney York to "exchange" it.

    I said: "There is a difference in buying dollars so i can get paid in dollars and sending MY money to America to exchange that amount in dollars... She didn't understand this logic... maybe i'm the one who doesn't understand things about banking... could be...


    Well... Then... From Bank B in New York MY money is transferred to Bank C... also in New York.... for what reason... I absolutely have no clue...
    Even my own bank hasn't got a clue on this...

    Then... From Bank C in New York , MY money is send to my bank in Holland... Bank D....

    There I receive my money in USDollars with a dicrepancy of around 4,50 dollars... which is eaten by all the banks it saw on it's way to my bank.
    Then my bank has to exchange it into euro's and then i see MY amount received in euro's in my bankstatement...


    Woudn't it be easier if Bank A just paid me in euro's?
    why do banks send money to US to transfer it into dollars?
    When it comes to banks everything is untransparent... i wonder why....
    Half troll half amazing!
  • Jel
    Confirmed User
    • Feb 2007
    • 6904

    #2
    sounds like it goes to an intermediary bank... not all banks accepts wires from point A, so it goes via a bank that does, and that 4.50 is the intermediary fee.

    So Bank B = intermediary, bank C is the one that can't recieve from Bank A, but they can recieve from Bank B

    especially as the amount is the same each time, and not a variable due to the exchange rate that day.

    Comment

    • Struggle4Bucks
      Sieg Hi!
      • May 2011
      • 3615

      #3
      discrepancy...
      Half troll half amazing!

      Comment

      • Struggle4Bucks
        Sieg Hi!
        • May 2011
        • 3615

        #4
        Originally posted by Jel
        sounds like it goes to an intermediary bank... not all banks accepts wires from point A, so it goes via a bank that does, and that 4.50 is the intermediary fee.

        So Bank B = intermediary, bank C is the one that can't recieve from Bank A, but they can recieve from Bank B.
        Bank A and Bank B are the same company... one is in London and the other is the New York office of that same bank. So Bank C cannot receive from Bank A although Bank B is the same bank as Bank A except the location is different?

        Originally posted by Jel
        especially as the amount is the same each time, and not a variable due to the exchange rate that day.
        amount is everytime different...
        Half troll half amazing!

        Comment

        • Struggle4Bucks
          Sieg Hi!
          • May 2011
          • 3615

          #5
          With this globalization in the world there are still situations where a Bank C cannot receive from a Bank A?
          Half troll half amazing!

          Comment

          • Jel
            Confirmed User
            • Feb 2007
            • 6904

            #6
            fuck knows then lol.

            And yep, mindblowing isn't it Though more likely intentional, as it generates a nice chunk extra for banks as a whole.

            Comment

            • Struggle4Bucks
              Sieg Hi!
              • May 2011
              • 3615

              #7
              Originally posted by Jel
              fuck knows then lol.

              And yep, mindblowing isn't it Though more likely intentional, as it generates a nice chunk extra for banks as a whole.
              lol....

              Yes... for us $4,50 is peanuts... even a to small amount to even ask about it... but think about all transaction like this all around...
              must be a huge money maker...
              Half troll half amazing!

              Comment

              • Struggle4Bucks
                Sieg Hi!
                • May 2011
                • 3615

                #8
                Originally posted by Jel
                especially as the amount is the same each time, and not a variable due to the exchange rate that day.
                The amount they "eat" is the same everytime... The amount that is tranferred (my money)
                is different every week...
                Half troll half amazing!

                Comment

                • Jel
                  Confirmed User
                  • Feb 2007
                  • 6904

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Struggle4Bucks
                  The amount they "eat" is the same everytime... The amount that is tranferred (my money)
                  is different every week...
                  ah right, I thought the eaten amount was different. So it is a fixed fee, so in turn the explanation they gave doesn't make sense about having to buy $ etc.

                  Are you 100% the banks are the same (A & B)? eg lloyds business is a separate entity than lloyds personal banking even though they are the same bank - so hazarding another guess, it's a way for them to engineer this charge by going through the 'intermediary'. However the specifics, that's where I'm semi-cautiously betting the discrepancy is.

                  Comment

                  • aka123
                    Confirmed User
                    • Jul 2014
                    • 4450

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Struggle4Bucks
                    My money goes from Bank A in London (i thought i had an American processor) to Bank B in Ney York, because i am paid in dollars and Bank A is in euro area so they need to "buy" dollars so my amount is send to Bank B in Ney York to "exchange" it.

                    I said: "There is a difference in buying dollars so i can get paid in dollars and sending MY money to America to exchange that amount in dollars... She didn't understand this logic... maybe i'm the one who doesn't understand things about banking... could be...
                    Maybe she meant that they sell the euros, pounds, etc. to US bank and they send USDs back. And there is exchange fee for that transaction.

                    It is not your's money by the way. It is bank's money, as long as bank has it. Bank just ows to you.

                    Comment

                    • Mediamix
                      Dutch Webmaster!
                      • Sep 2013
                      • 3228

                      #11
                      Banks are a bunch of bastards!
                      Sig too big

                      Comment

                      • RebelR
                        Confirmed User
                        • Feb 2005
                        • 1998

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Struggle4Bucks
                        The amount they "eat" is the same everytime... The amount that is tranferred (my money)
                        is different every week...
                        It must be some sort of handling fee, for one bank to process it. But it seems odd that it wouldn't be included in your bank's wire fee. Just curious as to why you wouldn't have a USD account in the NL. That way you can receive in USD without having to be subject to the rate at the time the money is transferred. You could wait until the rates are favourable to you.
                        Rich"at"rebel-ads.com
                        ICQ 644377336 or MSN ruralx"at"hotmail.com

                        Comment

                        • 2MuchMark
                          Mark of 2Much.net
                          • Aug 2004
                          • 50968

                          #13
                          There is also a difference in currency conversion between what a bank sells currency for, and what it pays for that currency. For example, a bank may sell $1 USD for $1.14 CAD, but pay $1.15 CAD to get it, even on the same day and same time.

                          If you can find a way to be more efficient with your banks, do it, and put some of those fees into your pocket.

                          Comment

                          Working...