Originally Posted by jayeff

If you have all this time to spare posting here, but not for emailing an opinion to ICANN, at least try to write something intelligent.

The point about the xxx TLD issue is not that the sky will fall in, but that at best it represents an expense which will generate no-one but registrars and domain speculators any return. That alone should be enough reason to oppose the introduction of this TLD.

However, a specific TLD for porn does open the door for political opportunism. In that case, your response is to rely on the law, but the law is not static and it is also expensive, uncertain and time consuming.

I doubt that anyone emailing ICANN is very optimistic that their opinions will be counted. But given what is at stake, your attempt to make a virtue out of doing nothing at all is sad and foolish.