The time it took you to write that long post you could've sold more porn and had enough to buy both consoles and judge for yourself.
seriously though:
SELL MORE PORN = BUY BOTH CONSOLES
You say you're a true "gamer", yet your post seems more like all the fanboy flamewars on 1up & IGN, etc... most true "gamers" that are members of my mainstream sites buy all consoles and portables. It's ALL about the gameplay... PERIOD. Doesn't matter if your passion is Tetris, EQ, Halo, Final Fantasy or Steel Battalion... it boils down to whatever games help you escape reality & enjoy what little free time you have. Just play.
The only thing I hate about the 360 is that my techie's expecting ME to drop $1000 next week for his 360bundle as an early xmas gift.

I want to, but I know it'll mean that he won't get any work done.
.