150 music experts
The Beatles vs. Nirvana : which made a stronger impact on music?
Collapse
X
-
Comment
-
The Beatles had much more impact - I'm not really their biggest fan, partly because I've only really gone out and made a point to listen to their music recently - if you just heard them now for the first time, their music just sounds like the same old, same old.
Why? Because every band on the planet has copied their song structures & created a million reworks of their songs since then.
But, then, when I conceptualize that when they first recorded these songs NO ONE was doing music like this, I gain a lot more respect for them.Comment
-
What albums have you listened to?Originally posted by badmunchkin
The Beatles had much more impact - I'm not really their biggest fan, partly because I've only really gone out and made a point to listen to their music recently - if you just heard them now for the first time, their music just sounds like the same old, same old.
Why? Because every band on the planet has copied their song structures & created a million reworks of their songs since then.
But, then, when I conceptualize that when they first recorded these songs NO ONE was doing music like this, I gain a lot more respect for them.Comment
-
Comment
-
ummm...Originally posted by Joe Citizen
What albums have you listened to?
The White Album
Abbey Road
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
Revolver
Magical Mystery TourComment
-
Originally posted by badmunchkin
ummm...
The White Album
Abbey Road
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
Revolver
Magical Mystery Tour
Don't forget Rubber Soul.Comment
-
The Beatles made a strong impact in the history of music. I don't think any boy band can surpass the popularity they achieved.Click Here to get $42 a sale AND Get FREE MGP Coaching from WebmasterLabor.Com
Sign up above then EMAIL info (( at )) webmasterlabor DOT com for your free 1 to 1 MGP coaching

Comment
-
Explain?Originally posted by Manowar
they both sucked beefy cock
Need Mainstream Content and SEO?
SEO * Website Copy * Blogs
Blogging - PR Work - Forum Marketing - Social Marketing - Link building - Articles
100% Guaranteed Content!
Comment
-
Comparing a boy band to the Beatles is like comparing a midget to Yao Ming in terms of basketball prowess.Originally posted by pure energy
The Beatles made a strong impact in the history of music. I don't think any boy band can surpass the popularity they achieved.
Need Mainstream Content and SEO?
SEO * Website Copy * Blogs
Blogging - PR Work - Forum Marketing - Social Marketing - Link building - Articles
100% Guaranteed Content!
Comment
-
Punk?Originally posted by pimplink
Nirvana basically made PUNK mainstream. Punk is more of a sensibility rather than any discrete musical style. It's liberating Do It Yourself attitude stands in stark contrast to the corporate machinery and counterculture naivette that made the Beatles the top act of the 60s.
26 + 6 = 1Comment
-
Eddie Van Halen once said of grunge (Nirvana specifically) "I'm sure they'll be much better when they learn a few more chords".
Nirvana esencially put hard "rock" to power chords. Where have we seen this before? Ramones. Pixies.
Nirvana was by no means the origin of that "style" of music..Comment
-
Originally posted by pimplink
Comparing a boy band to the Beatles is like comparing a midget to Yao Ming in terms of basketball prowess.
Not true, the beetles where made not original just like the buy bands now. They did what they where told for years before doing their own ideas. They where broke and had no choice but to sell out.
That's why it's a good argument Nirvana never sold out. Basically they where pure suger no sweet and low.Like the desert needs the rain
We do fully manged WordPress, VPS, and Servers. Adult Host Pro https://adulthostpro.com/ Since 2001Comment
-
Grunge needs to learn more chords?Originally posted by WarChild
Eddie Van Halen once said of grunge (Nirvana specifically) "I'm sure they'll be much better when they learn a few more chords".
Nirvana esencially put hard "rock" to power chords. Where have we seen this before? Ramones. Pixies.
Nirvana was by no means the origin of that "style" of music.
Wow I just lost allot of respect for Eddie if thats true.
Important: Music is not how many chords you can cram in a riff it's what feeling you get from the songs not just the guitar.
If talent and note structure waswhat music was all about then we would all listen to classical and rock would of never been formed.Like the desert needs the rain
We do fully manged WordPress, VPS, and Servers. Adult Host Pro https://adulthostpro.com/ Since 2001Comment
-
Are Pearl Jam or Metallica boy bands also?Originally posted by pure energy
I don't think any boy band can surpass the popularity they achieved.
Idiot.Comment
-
You know nothing about the Beatles.Originally posted by chaze
Not true, the beetles where made not original just like the buy bands now. They did what they where told for years before doing their own ideas. They where broke and had no choice but to sell out.
That's why it's a good argument Nirvana never sold out. Basically they where pure suger no sweet and low.
You're embarrasing yourself.Comment
-
Are you sure it's not you that doesn't knowOriginally posted by Joe Citizen
You know nothing about the Beatles.
You're embarrasing yourself.
I have been in bands since I was twelve and have read every detail about the beatles.
What's your experiance Johny Carson?
Did you know they got bood off the stage for years before getting signed and had to sleep in rat infested hotels because they where broke?
Maybe the record label said do whatever you want and we will make you rich. I think that what they say to every broke talented band. (Sarcasm in case you missed it)
Is that really what you think?
They just wanted to play and didn't mind acting the part to be able too.Last edited by chaze; 09-16-2004, 03:19 AM.Like the desert needs the rain
We do fully manged WordPress, VPS, and Servers. Adult Host Pro https://adulthostpro.com/ Since 2001Comment
-
Today's Punk music is tommorow's Rock Music.Originally posted by chodadog
Punk?
It's all about attitude
Need Mainstream Content and SEO?
SEO * Website Copy * Blogs
Blogging - PR Work - Forum Marketing - Social Marketing - Link building - Articles
100% Guaranteed Content!
Comment
-
In 5 years nobody will remember NirvanaComment
-
On a second thought.
Nobody remembers them even now.
They live normal lives hidding form none, because none is interested in them.
Besides Cobain (RIP) the rest of them are pretty much worthless junkies.Comment
-
Nirvana is highly over-rated. They did influence other bands at the time, but that brand of music (and virtually all forms of grunge-rock) is as dead these days as Cobain himself.
What Nirvana influenced simply did not stand the test of time, nor did any bands who took a page out of their book.
Look at what's been really popular over the last decade. None of it was Dependant upon Nirvana.
I think more credit should go to the early days of both Green Day (Dookie was just huge for the future of music) and the Smashing Pumpkins.Comment
-
lol...as soon as I saw the pic that song went into my head. Atleast he isn't cliff richard but the sad thing is that while most people in the US haven't heard of Sir Cliff HE had much more impact on music than Nirvana by FAR.Originally posted by Tipsy
That alone must have made the move worthwhile. Until you've heard his version of 'This 'ol house' you haven't lived!Comment
-
One more person that I knew would react to that comment crossed off my list.Originally posted by chodadog
Punk?
Comment
-
are you saying that because they had a good producer they wer a boy b(l)and? Give me a break if you think Nirvana never listened to their record label.Originally posted by chaze
Not true, the beetles where made not original just like the buy bands now. They did what they where told for years before doing their own ideas. They where broke and had no choice but to sell out.
That's why it's a good argument Nirvana never sold out. Basically they where pure suger no sweet and low.Comment
-
Originally posted by pimplink
Today's Punk music is tommorow's Rock Music.
It's all about attitude
no, no it isn't. Nirvana were NEVER punk even if they did have a 'fuck you' attitude. That is like when Avril whats her face calls herself punk and I want to kick her ass.Comment
-
She doesn't call herself punk. She's actually said the exact opposite. They can't figure out why people call them punk.Originally posted by sarah_webinc
That is like when Avril whats her face calls herself punk and I want to kick her ass.
She dresses that skater style, so people who don't really know her music see that and figure she's punk. Then it snowballs from there.Comment
-
No one remember them now! Just whoever started this post.Originally posted by Praguer
In 5 years nobody will remember NirvanaComment
-
you know too much about herOriginally posted by Matt 26z
She doesn't call herself punk. She's actually said the exact opposite. They can't figure out why people call them punk.
She dresses that skater style, so people who don't really know her music see that and figure she's punk. Then it snowballs from there.Comment
-
Comment





Comment