Originally posted by iceicebaby the whole reason is to promote GFY.... rules are rules
ROUND THREE CHALLENGE: This rounds challenge is to produce the best pic of yourself in the GFY tank top and panties. The best pic wins the $500 round 3 prize. 10 Girls will be knocked out this round. Since we are mailing the clothes, the round will end on June 11.
I can assume that she is wearing the GFY tank and thong but that wasn't the point of the photo contest.
Lets bring up another point... correct me if Im wrong but didn't Kitty drop out because she lives in Austraila or something like that and didn't get her GFY gear in time? Im sure she could have found a generic white tank and thong to take a picture in.
Although the pic is very nice and well done, there could have been an effort made to take a pic with the GFY logo showing.
I say she should be disqualified.
Just my
Sorry Ice but this is not true. Kitty didn't go to the FEd Ex station where the package was sitting for a week or so and get it. We got it back here in the office a week ago after FedEx returned it to us. Major difference there.
Originally posted by Digipimp really you shouldn't even bother defending yourself, it's gay that this is brought up. i am positive it wasn't lensman that thought it up, but it was brought to him.
Thank you!! I am very pissed off that I went to all this trouble to make a good pic, and now they think I didn't wear the top and panties. I posted another pic in this thread btw. One where the logo is showing. WTF would I pose in the exact same gear without the logo while I have the GFY gear at home??
ROUND THREE CHALLENGE: This rounds challenge is to produce the best pic of yourself in the GFY tank top and panties. The best pic wins the $500 round 3 prize. 10 Girls will be knocked out this round. Since we are mailing the clothes, the round will end on June 11.
She is in her GFY tank top and panties. So she's not showing the logo, if you wanted that, you would have said it. No reason to disqualify her if you ask me, she did as the challenge said.
Originally posted by iceicebaby Lets bring up another point... correct me if Im wrong but didn't Kitty drop out because she lives in Austraila or something like that and didn't get her GFY gear in time? Im sure she could have found a generic white tank and thong to take a picture in.
Although the pic is very nice and well done, there could have been an effort made to take a pic with the GFY logo showing.
I say she should be disqualified.
Just my
Thank you. That was the point I tried to make several posts back. Without remembering Kitty's name, though, I don't know how much sense it made.
Originally posted by Eric_aka_RedEyes Sorry Ice but this is not true. Kitty didn't go to the FEd Ex station where the package was sitting for a week or so and get it. We got it back here in the office a week ago after FedEx returned it to us. Major difference there.
Me bad..... I stand corrected... Ty for clearing that up Eric
Originally posted by fuelcell no offense meant, but it shoulda been obvious to include the gfy logo in the submitted picture
Doesn't matter what you think is obvious..it was not spelled out in the rules.
Go read a fucking cereal box contest...see how much legalese there is in that shit..read the back of a lottery ticket..they hire lawyers and companies to handle this kind of stuff for a reason....to avoid situations like this.
Make big money on your Domains! Why wait 40 days to get paid with the other guys? Parked.com pays the most for your traffic, and cuts checks twice a month!
Originally posted by Trixie Racer Thank you. That was the point I tried to make several posts back. Without remembering Kitty's name, though, I don't know how much sense it made.
Originally posted by iceicebaby the whole reason is to promote GFY.... rules are rules
ROUND THREE CHALLENGE: This rounds challenge is to produce the best pic of yourself in the GFY tank top and panties. The best pic wins the $500 round 3 prize. 10 Girls will be knocked out this round. Since we are mailing the clothes, the round will end on June 11.
I can assume that she is wearing the GFY tank and thong but that wasn't the point of the photo contest.
Lets bring up another point... correct me if Im wrong but didn't Kitty drop out because she lives in Austraila or something like that and didn't get her GFY gear in time? Im sure she could have found a generic white tank and thong to take a picture in.
Although the pic is very nice and well done, there could have been an effort made to take a pic with the GFY logo showing.
I know for a fact that several ladies had major issues with receiving the clothing. I think a couple of foreign ladies even dropped out because of the distance issue. It is only fair to be firm with the flavor of the rules when people already suffered because of them. There is a reason why a GFY logo was required: Branding the site and the contest. I'm sorry but it was a requirement in selecting the submission to use the outfit branded. How come she was the only one that submitted non-GFY logo picture? Everyone else did to one degree or another.
Originally posted by eroswebmaster You can "think" what you want to...but the unpopular position will be that you didn't specify it in the rules...so how can she break a rule that does not exist?
The age of common sense and reason have passed us by.
I'm certainly not a contestant...those who know me know that beauty and youth have been replaced with wisdom and wit....
Having said that, didn't I read in the beginning that Miss Gfy should possess skills and talents and intelligence, along with beauty?
So, it seems to me, that, while it wasn't the letter of the rules, there is the spirit of the rules to be considered.
I'm not voting either way; but common sense dictates the logo should show, since it's a gfy contest and specific attire was required. Why bother having a logo on a shirt if it doesn't matter whether it's seen?
Originally posted by NakedBo Thank you!! I am very pissed off that I went to all this trouble to make a good pic, and now they think I didn't wear the top and panties. I posted another pic in this thread btw. One where the logo is showing. WTF would I pose in the exact same gear without the logo while I have the GFY gear at home??
Originally posted by twistyneck Let her stay. It's already been said that she didn't break any rules and if you wanted the logo to be in the picture that should have been stated.
Since there was no violation of the contest rules the are no legitimate grounds for disqualification. Of course it was implied that the letters "GFY" would be seen however it was not stated as a requirement. I'm sure her decision not to show the letters "GFY" will be reflected in the voting results (both the masses and the judges).
oh and if you wanted the ladies to interpret the rules to mean things they don't say then you shouldn't have voted some of the smarter ladies out and you should have had some contenst that weren't just about T&A.
Originally posted by WiredGuy The instructions are pretty clear:
She is in her GFY tank top and panties. So she's not showing the logo, if you wanted that, you would have said it. No reason to disqualify her if you ask me, she did as the challenge said.
WG
I agree. She didn't break the rules... the Rules don't have the work "Logo" in them at all.
If you disqualify her for not showing the logo, why not disqualify people who didn't show the tag of the panties???? The rules didn't say that either.
Jupiter Hosting, Inc.
Vice President, Business Development
kc (AT) jupiterhosting.com
Originally posted by Lensman Big debate in our office.
Argument for disqualification:
Some think she should be disqualified because the GFY logo is not in the pic and "it's a given" that it should be.
Argument against:
The rules do not say you have to see the logo.
Let the masses decide!
Make no mistake, she is hot as hell! But do no vote on that.
Here are the Round 3 instructions:
ROUND THREE CHALLENGE: This rounds challenge is to produce the best pic of yourself in the GFY tank top and panties. The best pic wins the $500 round 3 prize. 10 Girls will be knocked out this round. Since we are mailing the clothes, the round will end on June 11.
Some girls are not even " in " the shirts or panties ( #3 and #12 )
Originally posted by Digipimp oh and if you wanted the ladies to interpret the rules to mean things they don't say then you shouldn't have voted some of the smarter ladies out and you should have had some contenst that weren't just about T&A.
Er... that is silly. All the other candidates were smart enough to submit a logo'ed photo.
Originally posted by xxxdesign-net What about people that werent IN their panties ??
You know... I will agree with you there. Angeleyes and I had that discussion when taking her picture. We both wondered if she would be disqualified or not for not wearing them..... thats why we created the illusion that she is getting ready for a midnight skinny dip kinda thing.
My first post was based on the fact that I thought kitty should have been able to wear generic tank and thong to stay in. I didn't know that she didn't pick it up in a timely manner until Eric responded a few posts ago.
The rules were not very specific and I can understand that this is more for fun than anything and thats why Lensman didn't get a team of lawyers in to produce iron clad rules. But you know alot of these girls are gonna look for any possible way to gain an advantage.
So based on the above... fuck it let her stay in. I just didn't know about the kitty situation and was trying to be fair. I still say more effort could have been made to at least show the GFY logo...
I got the outfit, emailed Loryn that I did, so why should I go pose in another outfit that the GFY outfit. I posted another pic in this thread with the logo showing, and I already offered Loryn that if they need pics to promote GFY I will be happy to send them the pics I took with the logo showing. Nothing in the rules sayed that the logo has to show, and since I thought the pic that I submitted was the most sexy one I mailed them that one, if I would have known this would have been such an issue I would have submitted another one.
Originally posted by KC I agree. She didn't break the rules... the Rules don't have the work "Logo" in them at all.
If you disqualify her for not showing the logo, why not disqualify people who didn't show the tag of the panties???? The rules didn't say that either.
common... how stupid do you have to be? the contest was "Miss GFY"... right? you have to be in the tank and panties... of course the logo has to show... otherwise... it is just another contest. right?
But then again... these girls are not the brightest bulbs on the billboard.
Well if the rules did not state explicitly that the logo must be visible then I say she gets to stay, but only on a technicality. I would also make sure that all contestants understand that the GFY Logo must be clearly visible in the next round. Oh yeah, and then I would spank her hot little bum to teach her a lesson.
I think she's a hottie...it's too bad that this is even an issue...at first I thought maybe because the GFY logo isn't showing that she should be disqualified from winning round 3, but I do not think she should be out of the whole contest since this wasn't even brought up until after the voting was done...If it was an issue it should have been handled before the voting began, like the fisting photo was...I say let her pass through to round 4...
Originally posted by NBDesign common... how stupid do you have to be? the contest was "Miss GFY"... right? you have to be in the tank and panties... of course the logo has to show... otherwise... it is just another contest. right?
But then again... these girls are not the brightest bulbs on the billboard.
Originally posted by NBDesign common... how stupid do you have to be? the contest was "Miss GFY"... right? you have to be in the tank and panties... of course the logo has to show... otherwise... it is just another contest. right?
But then again... these girls are not the brightest bulbs on the billboard.
and she's shown another pic in this thread showing the logo, you can go ahead and shut up now.
Originally posted by Lensman I agree with that one!
I posted one in this thread, and if I have to resubmit the girls who didn't wear it should do that too. I swear that if I knew that this was an issue I would have submitted an other one. Why is this brought up after the voting. I submitted mine on time, and if you would have said that it had to show the logo I would have send you guys another one.
Originally posted by Lensman I agree with that one!
I think we should just keep her in.
What is she going to submit another pic for? Would we be voting all over again? Just let her move on. She didn't break any rules.
Comment