I have a friend who claims to be a witch (excuse me, Wiccan). We used to argue quite a bit about her beliefs in not just wicca but extrasensory perception and other things seemingly contrary to scientific fact.
Finally, in a debate over whether something she believed was scientifically factual, she said, "How can you be such a supporter of science. Science has a history of changing its mind. Scientists used to believe in humors and that all space was permeated by ether, but now they believe those theories are false."
What I said finally shut her up on the subject forever: "I believe in science precisely because it DOES have a procedure for changing its mind. It was never an immutable doctrine that humors or ether existed. Science was ready to consider new ideas and admit it had been wrong based on the evidence. When was the last time Wicca admitted to getting anything wrong?"
Deadly silence...
Let's bring this back to what we read on this board today.
I have never heard a single conspiracy theorist admit they were ever wrong about any of the wild theories they propound. Why? Because these theories are not theories at all, subject to disconfirmation based on fact, but rather immutable doctrines which they have taken a silent vow to defend to the death.
Massivecock et al, is there no single weird or wild or outrageous conspiracy theory you've offered that turned out to be wrong? If so, let's hear about it now.
Finally, in a debate over whether something she believed was scientifically factual, she said, "How can you be such a supporter of science. Science has a history of changing its mind. Scientists used to believe in humors and that all space was permeated by ether, but now they believe those theories are false."
What I said finally shut her up on the subject forever: "I believe in science precisely because it DOES have a procedure for changing its mind. It was never an immutable doctrine that humors or ether existed. Science was ready to consider new ideas and admit it had been wrong based on the evidence. When was the last time Wicca admitted to getting anything wrong?"
Deadly silence...
Let's bring this back to what we read on this board today.
I have never heard a single conspiracy theorist admit they were ever wrong about any of the wild theories they propound. Why? Because these theories are not theories at all, subject to disconfirmation based on fact, but rather immutable doctrines which they have taken a silent vow to defend to the death.
Massivecock et al, is there no single weird or wild or outrageous conspiracy theory you've offered that turned out to be wrong? If so, let's hear about it now.






Comment