XBIZ: ICANN to Consider Free-Form Top-Level Domains

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Iron Fist
    Too lazy to set a custom title
    • Dec 2006
    • 23400

    #1

    XBIZ: ICANN to Consider Free-Form Top-Level Domains

    ICANN to Consider Free-Form Top-Level Domains

    By Bob Preston
    Monday, Jun 23, 2008 Text size:
    CYBERSPACE ? In a move that could give the .XXX top-level domain a back-door onto the Internet, ICANN will vote Thursday on a proposal to relax requirements for top-level domains.

    If approved, the proposal could potentially let companies and individuals make up their own top-level domains in a fashion similar to how some countries have made use of the top-level domains assigned to them.

    For example, the top-level domain .tv was introduced in 1996 and eventually assigned to the the Polynesian island nation of Tuvalu. The country wound up cutting a deal to sell domains bearing the dot-TV ending to anybody, not just citizens and businesses of Tuvalu.

    In a similar fashion, companies and individuals might be able apply for their own unique top-level domain, which would cost "several thousand dollars" and be subject to a review process. Applicants would have to submit a business plan and demonstrate that their proposed top-level domain has some kind of "technical capacity."

    But such a fluid system raises the specter of a recent pain the in the adult industry's neck: .XXX. To date, ICANN has regulated the existence, if not the use, of most top-level domains, and if they were to approve this proposal on Thursday, then someone could simply submit .XXX for approval.

    Dr. Paul Twomey, chief executive of ICANN, said that the proposed new system would be open to anyone.

    The adult industry reached a near-consensus in its opposition to the .XXX top-level domain. Free Speech Coalition Chairman Jeffrey Douglas said that .XXX would have meant there would be an Internet ?ghettoization.?

    [click here for the rest of this article...]
    i like waffles
  • pocketkangaroo
    Confirmed User
    • Jan 2005
    • 8452

    #2
    This is one of the more important decisions ICANN has ever made. It's unfortunate it won't get many comments here, but I guess who's buying someone a beer at a show and how much board props they get is more important than actual business stuff.

    Comment

    • kane
      Too lazy to set a custom title
      • Aug 2001
      • 20684

      #3
      Yep, even if they approve this they could still choose not to allow the .xxx extension, but it would be pretty hard to stop it at that point.

      Comment

      • munki
        Do Fun Shit.
        • Dec 2004
        • 13393

        #4
        wtf.......

        I have the simplest tastes. I am always satisfied with the best.” -Oscar Wilde

        Comment

        • NewbieNudes
          Confirmed User
          • Jan 2003
          • 940

          #5
          Net result if that goes ahead, domains become way less important and everybody uses google to find every web site.

          Basically just gives more power to google.

          | Click Here to join our unique high converting program

          | Add yourself for free traffic!

          ICQ: 279 738 569 | Skype: NewbieNudes | Email: affiliates at newbienudes dot com

          Comment

          • JFK
            FUBAR the ORIGINATOR
            • Jan 2002
            • 67369

            #6
            are we going to get back doored ??

            FUBAR Webmasters - The FUBAR Times - FUBAR Webmasters Mobile - FUBARTV.XXX
            For promo opps contact jfk at fubarwebmasters dot com

            Comment

            • RevengeBucks_Monica
              Confirmed User
              • Sep 2007
              • 775

              #7
              An article I read stated that they could still reject submissions for top level domains for moral reasons etc... so perhaps they would reject the .xxx under that excuse, if enough people complained.
              The ORIGINAL & BEST CONVERTING EX-GIRLFRIEND REVENGE site!

              Revenge Bucks - Now with Morphing RSS Feeds!

              Email: monica @ revengebucks.com | ICQ:138-027-662 | AIM:RevengeMonica

              Comment

              • DocYall
                Confirmed User
                • Nov 2006
                • 149

                #8
                Originally posted by NewbieNudes
                Net result if that goes ahead, domains become way less important and everybody uses google to find every web site.

                Basically just gives more power to google.

                Definitely agree here. Makes SE placement that much more important.

                ICQ: 334973290

                Comment

                • NewbieNudes
                  Confirmed User
                  • Jan 2003
                  • 940

                  #9
                  I jUst pre-regsitered the TLD .tube just in case ;)
                  | Click Here to join our unique high converting program

                  | Add yourself for free traffic!

                  ICQ: 279 738 569 | Skype: NewbieNudes | Email: affiliates at newbienudes dot com

                  Comment

                  • GAMEFINEST
                    Make STACK$
                    • Nov 2006
                    • 14470

                    #10
                    i doubt it will go thru
                    Compound interest.

                    Comment

                    • tiger
                      Confirmed User
                      • Apr 2002
                      • 6986

                      #11
                      Why? What is wrong with the current system that they need to make changes this big?

                      Comment

                      • mike-al
                        Confirmed User
                        • Aug 2007
                        • 691

                        #12
                        Originally posted by tiger
                        Why? What is wrong with the current system that they need to make changes this big?
                        $
                        Delete this account, i am done here

                        Comment

                        • SomeCreep
                          :glugglug
                          • Mar 2003
                          • 26118

                          #13
                          Won't happen. With ICANN, nothing ever happens, except lots of talk and bureaucracy.

                          Webair Hosting

                          I use and recommend Webair for hosting.

                          Comment

                          • GatorB
                            The Demon & 12clicks
                            • Oct 2001
                            • 18208

                            #14
                            Originally posted by kane
                            Yep, even if they approve this they could still choose not to allow the .xxx extension, but it would be pretty hard to stop it at that point.

                            But what about .sex or .porn or .porno couldn't the owners of those tlds make a case that porn sites should have to use their TLD? If government madated that pornsites have to use .xxx I'm sure you could see lawsuits from the owners with .sex, .porn etc because those are equally valid for the use of porn sites.

                            Comment

                            • XPays
                              Team Player
                              • May 2004
                              • 13002

                              #15
                              it would be huge business for them if they could make it happen. vanity extensions would be nuts.
                              InterNext Expo Domain Auction Live Now thru Feb 5
                              HuntingMoon GFY Domains Marketplace is LIVE
                              XPays always pays! Top Site: * RealJasmine.com * + HotelHeiress® with The Paris Hilton Sex Video
                              Insert the HotelHeiress® HD FEED into your members areas
                              XPin.com Opening for Pin Partners Soonish
                              Mainstream Offers For Emailers and DomainersNONADULT.COM


                              Like Us!

                              Comment

                              • Socks
                                Confirmed User
                                • May 2002
                                • 8475

                                #16
                                I wonder how much for .cumdumpguttersluts TLD?

                                Comment

                                • million
                                  Confirmed User
                                  • Apr 2006
                                  • 789

                                  #17
                                  I've never liked this idea. Just imagine all companies in the world and maybe some ISPs blocking the whole xxx TLD, that means no one watching porn from office ... I can only see less customers with this.
                                  <sig spot goes here>

                                  Comment

                                  • kane
                                    Too lazy to set a custom title
                                    • Aug 2001
                                    • 20684

                                    #18
                                    Originally posted by GatorB
                                    But what about .sex or .porn or .porno couldn't the owners of those tlds make a case that porn sites should have to use their TLD? If government madated that pornsites have to use .xxx I'm sure you could see lawsuits from the owners with .sex, .porn etc because those are equally valid for the use of porn sites.
                                    It is a very good point. If all those existed all of them could make the argument. It would only really matter if the government passed a law stating that all adult sites had to exist on one of these TLDs. If that happened then the one that was chosen by the government would flourish and the others would probably end up worthless.

                                    Comment

                                    • Ron Bennett
                                      Confirmed User
                                      • Oct 2003
                                      • 1653

                                      #19
                                      Adding many thousands, let alone millions, of real (as opposed to say IDN aliases) TLDs would stress the root servers, and create a huge single point of failure for custom-vanity TLDs.

                                      Many ISPs / resolvers cache the root server addresses and the corresponding TLD zone data, so if the roots are unavailable / busy or whatever, it's generally a situation that can be worked around - that won't be true in a custom-vanity TLD situation. The upshot being that traditional, popular TLDs would end up being more reliable in such instances.

                                      And from a business aspect, such a scheme would in essance be a monopoly far worse than Internic ever was - because the root would directly be serving resource records (ie. name server addresses) for end-user domains in the custom-vanity TLDs.

                                      Bottom line, in my view, is custom-vanity TLDs (a glorified keyword system) is unlikely to happen anytime soon, if ever.

                                      Ron
                                      Domagon - Website Management and Domain Name Sales

                                      Comment

                                      • GatorB
                                        The Demon & 12clicks
                                        • Oct 2001
                                        • 18208

                                        #20
                                        Originally posted by Ron Bennett
                                        Adding many thousands, let alone millions, of real (as opposed to say IDN aliases) TLDs would stress the root servers, and create a huge single point of failure for custom-vanity TLDs.

                                        Many ISPs / resolvers cache the root server addresses and the corresponding TLD zone data, so if the roots are unavailable / busy or whatever, it's generally a situation that can be worked around - that won't be true in a custom-vanity TLD situation. The upshot being that traditional, popular TLDs would end up being more reliable in such instances.
                                        If everyone got off their asses an employed Ipv6 wouldn't that alleviate that issue?

                                        And from a business aspect, such a scheme would in essance be a monopoly far worse than Internic ever was - because the root would directly be serving resource records (ie. name server addresses) for end-user domains in the custom-vanity TLDs.
                                        Not to mention how much easier it is going to be for scammers to use phishing techniques to scam people.

                                        Comment

                                        Working...