You can't trust me to read... classic. I think I should feel insulted.. yet I don't
Wow.. a history lesson on GFY... who would have thought. Very insightful.. thank you. Why do I need to rent the movies? i can just download them from a torrent site for free, right?
Your biggest mistake is in thinking that every scenario outside of what has been defined is fair use.
You take something simple, like getting a tape from your friend, and copying it at your house because your VCR went to shit or your power went down, and then liken it to getting the same from Vladomir in Russia or Punjab in India via torrent. How can that be an apples to apples comparison??? In the first, this is someone you are very acquainted with and knowledgable of. Your intention is not to distribute the content widely. In the latter, you have no clue who the suppliers are and there is no control as to whom receives the content. Absolutely different thoughts entirely.
If your friend was in the habit of taking that tape recording, or CD, or whatnot, and not only sharing it with you down the street, but then going door to door and offering it to everyone in the neighborhood, nay the city or state, you now have problems and the original copyright holder would be on his ass without question. The scale has overcome the fair use intention. This is where your argument breaks down. Just because it may be acceptable at the basic level does not bring that assumption to the grandiose level and make it OK there.
For all that education you have (as you can obviously read beyond a 1st grade level), you should really investigate the two words Fair and Use. Where would you think it is FAIR for anyone to make items available when I should be the one controlling the financial distribution of them? It is competing with the distribution of my product... FREE vs. CHARGED... who honestly cares about anything beyond the fact that the ones traficking the FREE content are not controlling it properly. They would be no different than someone delivering controlled substances (prescribed medicines) without a license..... here ya go.. oh, you say you have a right to Morphine.. OK, I trust ya.. thanks!!!
For all your legal wrangling.. how can you not agree to the fact that it has gotten out of control and opinions such as yours continue to support that fact? I would be happy to support TPB if they didn't traffick in goods they have no right to distribute. Don't give me the bullshit of people having backups or recovering, as 99% of the files are current versions where the original purchaser would have recourse to interact with the seller. P2P is the same. You go to the law, but you never address responsibility and accountability. Why should the user be given such rights? I don't believe that they have been and I do believe that people twist and bend the laws to their own satisfaction.
You can call me an ass or idiot all you like, but your opinion is in supporting people that are taking money from the pockets of artists and producers. People really don't like to create something, just to learn that the current market has determined that their product can be distributed for free very easily and there are no controls that will reasonably stop it. It tends to piss people off when you fuck around with their pocketbooks and ability to make money. At that point, they could really give a flying fuck about you having the ability to backup Windows95 13 years down the road when their musical production or video production that was released last week is now being shared at a rate of 10,000 to every 1 that is sold. The more that happens, the less likely it is for the creators to continue what they are doing because they are getting fucked over. You can only have a free ride for so long before it comes back and bites you in the ass. Such as getting fined $220K for sharing music files.
Wow.. a history lesson on GFY... who would have thought. Very insightful.. thank you. Why do I need to rent the movies? i can just download them from a torrent site for free, right?
Your biggest mistake is in thinking that every scenario outside of what has been defined is fair use.
You take something simple, like getting a tape from your friend, and copying it at your house because your VCR went to shit or your power went down, and then liken it to getting the same from Vladomir in Russia or Punjab in India via torrent. How can that be an apples to apples comparison??? In the first, this is someone you are very acquainted with and knowledgable of. Your intention is not to distribute the content widely. In the latter, you have no clue who the suppliers are and there is no control as to whom receives the content. Absolutely different thoughts entirely.
If your friend was in the habit of taking that tape recording, or CD, or whatnot, and not only sharing it with you down the street, but then going door to door and offering it to everyone in the neighborhood, nay the city or state, you now have problems and the original copyright holder would be on his ass without question. The scale has overcome the fair use intention. This is where your argument breaks down. Just because it may be acceptable at the basic level does not bring that assumption to the grandiose level and make it OK there.
For all that education you have (as you can obviously read beyond a 1st grade level), you should really investigate the two words Fair and Use. Where would you think it is FAIR for anyone to make items available when I should be the one controlling the financial distribution of them? It is competing with the distribution of my product... FREE vs. CHARGED... who honestly cares about anything beyond the fact that the ones traficking the FREE content are not controlling it properly. They would be no different than someone delivering controlled substances (prescribed medicines) without a license..... here ya go.. oh, you say you have a right to Morphine.. OK, I trust ya.. thanks!!!
For all your legal wrangling.. how can you not agree to the fact that it has gotten out of control and opinions such as yours continue to support that fact? I would be happy to support TPB if they didn't traffick in goods they have no right to distribute. Don't give me the bullshit of people having backups or recovering, as 99% of the files are current versions where the original purchaser would have recourse to interact with the seller. P2P is the same. You go to the law, but you never address responsibility and accountability. Why should the user be given such rights? I don't believe that they have been and I do believe that people twist and bend the laws to their own satisfaction.
You can call me an ass or idiot all you like, but your opinion is in supporting people that are taking money from the pockets of artists and producers. People really don't like to create something, just to learn that the current market has determined that their product can be distributed for free very easily and there are no controls that will reasonably stop it. It tends to piss people off when you fuck around with their pocketbooks and ability to make money. At that point, they could really give a flying fuck about you having the ability to backup Windows95 13 years down the road when their musical production or video production that was released last week is now being shared at a rate of 10,000 to every 1 that is sold. The more that happens, the less likely it is for the creators to continue what they are doing because they are getting fucked over. You can only have a free ride for so long before it comes back and bites you in the ass. Such as getting fined $220K for sharing music files.



Comment