I'm shocked at how many people just don't get the funny part of it
He is not giving it to a stranger
When it's your friend/family, the idea is very smart and funny, I would laugh
When I heard that Tegan and Sarah song I thought it was damn funny, cause the guy was making more fun of himself and his stereotypical mind, I was surprised when realized so many people took it as an insult
Give her boxers

also some movie or book like this
Or a T-SHIRT
or a ticket to TS show

I'd love to get one