Robbie,
how do you begin to set the criteria for being allowed to stay? who gets a golden ticket and who gets axed?
i.e. someone like me. i have no public site of any consequence and haven't had one for years. i have no documents to submit to "verify" adult involvement, and even if i did, there's no way i'd ever submit such things to a messageboard for "approval". basically, the only thing i've got to "prove" my continued involvement in adult is my word, which just like everyone else, as only as good as [the final GFY Membership decision maker] feels it is.
then what about the peeps that were in adult, but have shifted into other areas but still enjoy reading, contributing, or "fucking around"? do they get in past the bouncer or left outside the club? what about the peeps trying to break into adult? should they come back after they've become successful enough to have proof that they belong?
i understand your frustration, but it's not like GFY is providing vast amounts of paid membership quality information or tutorials or something. you should already know the golden rule: if you want to offer exclusive membership, it needs to be worth it or you'll have no members. no members = death.
