View Single Post
Old 04-19-2010, 09:52 PM  
gideongallery
Confirmed User
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 7,082
Quote:
Originally Posted by kane View Post
Sorry, but this makes no sense. Why in a million years would he agree to turn all his content over into the public domain and get zero benefit or profit from it just so you can show him how you would make money with it? It is a no win situation for him.

If you do what you say you can do then he doesn't benefit from it, his competition does and all his content is out there for free. If you can't do it, he didn't benefit from it and all his content is still out there for free.
do you not understand what the word if means

go back up and look at what i said, i said IF he uses the techniques he must put any content that uses those techniques into the public domain

not that he must put it in the public domain BEFORE i show him the techniques

the only thing it does is prevent him from taking the techniques and pretending he came up with them on his own.


Quote:
So basically, you are asking a guy to give away something he has spent a lot of money creating just to give you the chance of showing that you are actually capable of doing what you claim.
no i am saying that he has to keep doing what he claims is working, and NOT use the techniques i am showing everyone.

he can't simply copy the changes i show one of the competitors and claim that he innovated the solution (ala his product placement i am creative for copying wayne's world bs)

Quote:
Try this in the mainstream world. Go to Sony records and tell them that you will show them how to make ton of money off of torrents, but in exchange for this knowledge they will have to turn their entire record catalog over to the public domain. They could use your techniques in the future, just not right now. The good news is that they will be taking it for the team and all their direct competition will get to benefit from their loss and the entire industry will see how great torrents really are. They get to be the martyr that saved the industry.

They would have you thrown out of the building.
well duh
that why i didn't say that

like i have now said 3 times he only has to put his content into the public domain if he uses the techniques
keep doing what he is currently doing he fine his content stays as exclusive as he has always been.
The only thing it prevents him from doing is taking the techniques and pretending that he figuired them out on his own.

the funny part is you quoted the statement when you made this Assinine reply

Quote:
the your content goes into the public domain if you use the techniques
__________________

“When crimes occur through the mail, you don’t shut the post office down,” Steve Wozniak
gideongallery is offline   Share thread on Digg Share thread on Twitter Share thread on Reddit Share thread on Facebook Reply With Quote