While I completely sympathize with the mom... this is utterly ridiculous. Ever since we started putting limits on what we can consensually do with our bodies, it?s undoubtedly just a matter of time before we?re back to banning interracial marriage. Slippery slopes indeed.
Mother to win ban on violent porn (UK News)
Collapse
X
-
Also noticed in the overall statement that they do not appear to have an interest in changing the actual guidelines of the OPA - you notice the stuff about "being in possession of"? (not for "publication"/sale/gain) Smells more like something where they want to "capture" individuals who have.... call them, "extreme interests".Originally posted by bizarredollarsIncludes - Meaning: not limited to (have you guessed I am a 'the glass half empty' kind of guy yet?).
But seriously, that is a little reassuring I suppose
.. They are far more likely to prosecute people with rape fantasy stuff, than they are consensual bdsm, deepthroating etc... Time will tell
XXX TLD's - Another mosquito to swat.Comment
-
From the home office statement "The material to be covered by the ban is already illegal to publish and distribute in the UK under the Obscene Publications Act (OPA) 1959."
From the IWF's notices on the OPA:
"The law on obscene publications is difficult to define in everyday terms.
As a guide it could include images featuring acts of extreme sexual activity such as bestiality, necrophilia, rape or torture. "
No mention of consentual BDSM (I would not class S&M as torture, but that is just my opinion). However, the IWF makes no mention of Scat (fecophilia) or Watersports (Urolagnia) - both of which have been, and continue to be prosecuted under OPA.
However, straightward rough sex and bondage are a far cry from the above mentioned acts.Last edited by bizarredollars; 08-30-2006, 06:35 AM.Comment
-
-
But the problem is we can't be sure because unless the material clearly contravines this act ( rape, snuff films ect ), then any possible prosecutions are going to be on a case by case basis relying on the political climate of the time, ( probably over-reactive to begin with ), and the collective common sense and decency of juries which could lead to something of a judical lottery.However, straightward rough sex and bondage are a far cry from the above mentioned acts.
The 1959 OPA act is already a little fuzzy and is open to some degree of interpretation and I think this new act is going to make things even worse to the point that it may force much of the British BDSM scene back underground.
One thing that does suprise me is that this new act seems to focus more on possesion rather than distribution placing much more onus on the "man/woman in the street" to make sure that they are in legal compliance with the afore mentioned "fuzzy" 1959 OPA - I wonder how many of them are even aware this act even exists ?
That could turn out to be a very interesting point........So what about movies from Hollywood, such as Deliverance? They are getting banned aswell?Laughing Out LoudComment
-
I am so happy to live in DenmarkOriginally posted by bizarredollarsIf my memory serves me correctly (it is several years since I researched this), in Denmark, when they removed all censorship, sex crime rates fell very significantly?
Off course childporn etc is illegal, but otherwise you can pretty much do what you want as long as both parties agree on what is going on.
Off course there are sexcrimes in Denmark as well. There will always be sick bastards out there no matter what. But it is not really that much.Comment
-
Presumably you'd like to see people imprisonned for looking at this gallery then? Oh my heavens, doesn't she look like Venice?Originally posted by xcitecashIts about time the words sex and violence were seperated as they should be !!!Comment
-
I am so happy we will be living in Denmark soon too. Four weeks to goOriginally posted by KatinkaI am so happy to live in Denmark
Off course childporn etc is illegal, but otherwise you can pretty much do what you want as long as both parties agree on what is going on.
.
Comment
-
Support for porn ban but doubts remain
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/b...re/5298700.stm
The government's proposal to ban the possession of violent and extreme pornographic material has been widely welcomed.
But will it be enforceable?
Under new laws announced on Wednesday by Home Office minister Vernon Coaker MP, anyone caught with images "featuring violence that is, or appears to be, life-threatening or is likely to result in serious and disabling injury", could be jailed for up to three years.
Groups representing adults who engage in more extreme but consensual sexual activities say the legislation represents a grey area.
Derek Cohen, secretary of The Spanner Trust, which defends the rights of sadomasochists of all sexual orientations, said the proposed legislation was more of a "knee-jerk reaction".
"The difficulty is that you have people who are in consensual activities and people engaged in more violent activities," he said.
"The difficulty in legislation is can you draw a line?"
Mr Cohen said that unlike child pornography or bestial pornography, which was easily recognisable as illegal, sadomasochists will find it difficult to know what side of the law their pictures fell.
He added: "Violence is not consensual but injuries can be received in all forms of activities. People will not know whether their pictures are illegal or not.
"It's a very difficult area, I think the burden of proof has to be very high. If this goes through I hope it receives a lot more scrutiny."
Mainstream unaffected
The government move follows a wide consultation process after a campaign led by Reading mother Liz Longhurst.
Her daughter Jane was killed by Graham Coutts, who was said to have been addicted to violent porn.
The new law will ensure possession of violent and extreme pornography is illegal both on- and offline.
The government says the new law will not target those who accidentally come into contact with obscene pornography, nor would it target the mainstream entertainment industry.
Jim Gamble, chief executive of the Child Exploitation and Online Protection (CEOP) Centre, said legislation was needed to keep in step with technological advances.
"Today starts to answer that need in respect of how the internet can be used to supplement this area of criminality.
"It builds on the fundamentals of the Obscene Publications Act 1959 and helps take our fight against violent and extreme pornography to where it needs to be - in tune with technology and in-line with how the modern criminal mind works," he said.
Others, such as Liberal Democrat MP and campaign supporter Sandra Gidley, say the government should have acted sooner.
"It's absolutely the right decision. The scandal is it's taken so long to come to this decision.
"You cannot look at this sort of material and not be affected."
Labour's Brighton Pavilion MP David Lepper added: "I'm delighted that our campaign has been so successful and that the government has agreed to plug these loopholes in the law."
But Shaun Gabb, director of the anti-censorship organisation the Libertarian Alliance opposes the legislation on the grounds that people should be able to look at whatever they wish.
"If you are criminalising possession then you are giving police inquisitorial powers to come into your house and see what you've got, now we didn't have this in the past," he said.Comment
-
"It builds on the fundamentals of the Obscene Publications Act 1959 and helps take our fight against violent and extreme pornography to where it needs to be - in tune with technology and in-line with how the modern criminal mind works," he said.
What a very ignorant statement for Mr Gambles to make.
I would dearly love for the "wise" Mr Gambles to state exactly what the 1959 OPA stands for especialy with this new set of somewhat ambiguous "rules" bolted on top.
Since he is saying that "extreme pornography" is a product of a "criminal mind" I can only assume that his next step will be to very clearly state exactly what he considers as "extreme pornography" lest millions of Brits end up being criminalised out of his ignorance.
Unfortuatley I think Mr Gambles chief priority is towards his own political career and he's indulging in a spot of good old "Empire Building" riding on the back of the emotive issue surrounding this new legislation.Laughing Out LoudComment
-
Here is the usual standard: If you can look at a single image and KNOW it was consentual, then I doubt there we be an issue. I you look at an image of a girl bound at all four corners with someone choking her while fucking her, well... there is no way to know if that is a consentual act or not.
It isn't difficult to figure it out.
AlexComment
-
Originally posted by RawAlexHere is the usual standard: If you can look at a single image and KNOW it was consentual, then I doubt there we be an issue. I you look at an image of a girl bound at all four corners with someone choking her while fucking her, well... there is no way to know if that is a consentual act or not.
It isn't difficult to figure it out.
Alex
By what factual means are you basing your statement ?Laughing Out LoudComment
-
i think its just for realy extreme stuff like ummm sites where girls are kidnapped and have knives held top their throats and shit
but I know english cops and they don't use the laws they are intended to be used sometimes like when they searched my friend under the terrorism act last year and arrested him for pot when we were out cycling!Comment
-
Originally posted by ManowarI wonder what affect this will have on affiliates of programs such as DukeDollars. The government really are fucking stupid when it comes to putting in laws like this
lol, we're the only programs that have any type of rough sex? I can name 100 off the top of my head. every big program has a face fucking site etc etc. Do you think the UK is going to subcatergorize by whos penis goes deeper in a face or ass? lets get serious. They will go as far (if they do anything) to block anysite that contains any type of porn where the woman is not in a position of empowerment.
This will be pretty hard to enforce.
DukeComment
-
Originally posted by spannoi think its just for realy extreme stuff like ummm sites where girls are kidnapped and have knives held top their throats and shit
but I know english cops and they don't use the laws they are intended to be used sometimes like when they searched my friend under the terrorism act last year and arrested him for pot when we were out cycling!
Without any clear and exact guidlines we can't really be sure untill it's tested repeatedly in a court and that's the main problem with this legislation. IMVHO all this does is make a somewhat grey area even greyer.
It's going to be no defence for anyone to stand up in court and say - "Well I thought I was alright viewing this M'lud" if the jury thinks different.
Remember that in the UK legal system - Ignorance is no defence.Last edited by wizhard; 08-30-2006, 12:13 PM.Laughing Out LoudComment
-
-
Not really.This will be pretty hard to enforce.
Remember this new legislation is aimed more at the consumer rather than the distributor. Anyone who ever downloads anything remotely questionable had better never take their PC to PC World for repairs lest they get their collar felt.Laughing Out LoudComment
-
The exact line I heard somebody who supported the law say on the radio today when the reporter was asking what happens if you accidently download something that is violent (in spam, etc).Originally posted by wizhard
Remember that in the UK legal system - Ignorance is no defence.Comment
-
it isn't to do with hardcore..it is to do with 'violence'.Originally posted by DukeSkywalkersoftcore tours for uk traffic
dukeComment
-
Wow... so now you can get 3 years in jail for having a picture of Jesus on the cross. InterestingHttp://www.extremehole.com
**** CLOSED ****
400 HOURS of exclusive custom extreme content, already on external HD in Raw DV ready to encode.
over 150,000 exclusive images and more.Comment
-
I wonder how any of that makes sense when I think of all the violence in movies I see nowadays... For example the merciless torture that goes on in the movie 'Hostel' or images of some freak abusing sexually a young girl in a trailer in the movie 'Hills have Eyes' and then aiming a gun at a baby after shooting the mother in front of her kid's eyes... Then again people LOVE those movies and all we have for control on them is the age rating. People seem to think that its okay because we do not see actual images of sex or kids being killed. Still the idea is there and sorry but if a human is fucked up to the point of strangling someone he/she doesnt need no 'inspiration' whatsoever to do it. What makes me sad is that if a radical law has to be imposed on the porn biz because of events like that its gonna be us all that are going to suffer for really maybe 3% of the content on the net that supposedly leads to murder or rape. Fuh.Comment
-
Originally posted by GercoWow... so now you can get 3 years in jail for having a picture of Jesus on the cross. Interesting
I LOVE the way you think!!
Comment
-
Originally posted by MediachickI wonder how any of that makes sense when I think of all the violence in movies I see nowadays... For example the merciless torture that goes on in the movie 'Hostel' or images of some freak abusing sexually a young girl in a trailer in the movie 'Hills have Eyes' and then aiming a gun at a baby after shooting the mother in front of her kid's eyes... Then again people LOVE those movies and all we have for control on them is the age rating. People seem to think that its okay because we do not see actual images of sex or kids being killed. Still the idea is there and sorry but if a human is fucked up to the point of strangling someone he/she doesnt need no 'inspiration' whatsoever to do it. What makes me sad is that if a radical law has to be imposed on the porn biz because of events like that its gonna be us all that are going to suffer for really maybe 3% of the content on the net that supposedly leads to murder or rape. Fuh.
To be honest Mediachick I think this new legislation makes very little sense in the real world and is just another dangerous UK law brought in by a government increasingly obsessed with control by virtue of the concept of their own goodwill.
A "nice" government for "nice" people - anyone who doesn't fit in with their own middle class ideals had better watch out.Laughing Out LoudComment
-
Agreed. Still scary.Originally posted by wizhardTo be honest Mediachick I think this new legislation makes very little sense in the real world and is just another dangerous UK law brought in by a government increasingly obsessed with control by virtue of the concept of their own goodwill.
A "nice" government for "nice" people - anyone who doesn't fit in with their own middle class ideals had better watch out.
Comment
-
That should fololow pretty fast in the US.PornGuy skype me pornguy_epic
AmateurDough The Hottes Shemales online!
TChicks.com | Angeles Cid | Mariana Cordoba | MAILERS WELCOME!Comment
-
Comment
-
Think you are correct wizhard - it is directed more to the public than anyone who may qualify to fall under the Obscene Publications Act. The commercial aspect, as in website operation is already covered under the Act.Originally posted by wizhardNot really.
Remember this new legislation is aimed more at the consumer rather than the distributor. Anyone who ever downloads anything remotely questionable had better never take their PC to PC World for repairs lest they get their collar felt.
Underneath this policy change (and not just because of a recent trial), there are elements of serious stuff going on - it rarely has much to do with any commercial element - more filesharing type activity catering to pretty extreme "tastes". When ya have an individual with a preoccupation over, eg necrophilia, - lets be honest - the guy has a mental problem.
Same applies to prob a few other areas of "interest" including stuff like CP etc. Any law officer working on, eg child/death/rape type cases is only too aware of the extremes a minority of people will go towards, presumably, some sexual gratification and/or controlling situations. If there was not a death in one case - the conduct often is such that, if permitted to continue, there will be death.
Bottom line - can't see this law being much that should cause concern to webmasters - they are already covered under the OPA. Also doubt it is a problem for the average member of the public who may have downloaded some content. Suspect it is designed to intercept very extreme situations, and where they will probably not be uncovered until after the horse has bolted - and end up a substantive charge with the main charge being a murder or manslaughter offence.XXX TLD's - Another mosquito to swat.Comment
-
Originally posted by WebbyBottom line - can't see this law being much that should cause concern to webmasters - they are already covered under the OPA. Also doubt it is a problem for the average member of the public who may have downloaded some content. Suspect it is designed to intercept very extreme situations, and where they will probably not be uncovered until after the horse has bolted - and end up a substantive charge with the main charge being a murder or manslaughter offence.
I hope time proves you right Webby, but I suspect the somewhat ambiguous nature of this new legislation is going to cause problems and I also suspect that it has been deliberatly drafted in this way to give the authorities as much room to manuever as they can get. OK, there's stuff on and off the net that should never be allowed but in the BDSM scene there are various practices that while taking place between consenting adults are at risk of being criminalised by this act unless it's applied in a mature and sensible way lest it cause more errosion of personal freedoms.Last edited by wizhard; 08-31-2006, 12:56 PM.Laughing Out LoudComment
-
Comment






Comment