i think you need to brush up on your internet law chum - since the thief is using the feed for non-commerical purposes (putting his ref. code in the posts) - it is not covered by fair use and is intellectual property theft.
email his isp and get him shut down. you also can report him to the search engines and get him removed.
i think you need to brush up on your internet law chum - since the thief is using the feed for non-commerical purposes (putting his ref. code in the posts) - it is not covered by fair use and is intellectual property theft.
email his isp and get him shut down. you also can report him to the search engines and get him removed.
Using an RSS feed is not illegal, modifying, yes it is. I was referring to JUST using an RSS feed as is.
TNW: So are there legal reuses of RSS feed material?
Sunstein: No. Well, the longer answer is, yeah, maybe. It gets to be possible, but a lot of people put content on the Internet and expect it to be protected by copyright. You don't need notice of copyright. You haven't since Jan. 1, 1978. If you publish without a notice, it doesn't mean stuff isn't protected. If I put my stuff on the Internet without notice, I can still sue if someone redistributes my RSS feed.
And I guess if the front door to your home is open I can just walk in and take whatever the fuck i want right????
so fucking stupid.
I'd like to see you try to push in court that someone is using your RSS feed. Even if they modify the content of the feed, you'll still have a hard time. Thanks.
Using an RSS feed is not illegal, modifying, yes it is. I was referring to JUST using an RSS feed as is.
what determines fair use?
1. the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes;
2. the nature of the copyrighted work;
3. the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and
4. the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work.
having google ads or some such on a blog, whether it's altered or not, will not make your feed scraping fair use, if you're redistributing feeds without permission.
honestly, I don't see what the big fucking deal is. stripping links and replacing refcodes is fucked.
But being syndicated, benefits you if you know what you're doing.
If anyone wants to take my feed, please, go ahead just don't mod it and I won't have to send your host a DMCA
Yep, that's the problem. The guy the thread starter is talking about is stripping it all down to text, changing codes etc, and not giving any form of credit.
Yep, that's the problem. The guy the thread starter is talking about is stripping it all down to text, changing codes etc, and not giving any form of credit.
Utilizing an RSS feed as is, is legal. Modifying it is illegal.
Even if you don't modify it, you have no right to copy it to your own site if the creator did not give the permission no matter what. Even if you give credit... The term 'legal' is not really relevant because its about copyright, and it would be handled as a case between two private persons/companies.
Even if you don't modify it, you have no right to copy it to your own site if the creator did not give the permission no matter what. Even if you give credit... The term 'legal' is not really relevant because its about copyright, and it would be handled as a case between two private persons/companies.
I'd like to see you say that in court. You can claim copyright infringement, but you'd have one hell of a time winning because of the nature of RSS.
Don't mean to fuck with anyone or piss anybody off. Obviously my current RSS usage is doing exactly that... so I'm going to pull down the feeds and switch back to a prior site concept.
I very humbly apologize.
“I have the simplest tastes. I am always satisfied with the best.” -Oscar Wilde
I'd like to see you say that in court. You can claim copyright infringement, but you'd have one hell of a time winning because of the nature of RSS.
.. its about the final output, and the commercial value, that matters. If your work is not registered (like trademarks), has no real commercial value, no actual damage from the violation or the defendant has not gained from it.. then it would probably not be good enough for the court.
Court or not, its about respecting others work. RSS or whatever. Ask yourself "why you are doing it", not "do I get away with it".
Don't mean to fuck with anyone or piss anybody off. Obviously my current RSS usage is doing exactly that... so I'm going to pull down the feeds and switch back to a prior site concept.
I very humbly apologize.
Sounds like you got caught up in all the hype and forgot to take the blinders off. Glad you have seen the light
I can't speak for anyone else, but I imagine if you left links and what not alone you would be fine. In a way, those links could be considered 'payment' for the use of the content.
Anyway, good luck, it seems your apology is genuine.
Don't mean to fuck with anyone or piss anybody off. Obviously my current RSS usage is doing exactly that... so I'm going to pull down the feeds and switch back to a prior site concept.
...I imagine if you left links and what not alone you would be fine. In a way, those links could be considered 'payment' for the use of the content.
Anyway, good luck, it seems your apology is genuine.
TNW: So are there legal reuses of RSS feed material?
Sunstein: No. Well, the longer answer is, yeah, maybe. It gets to be possible, but a lot of people put content on the Internet and expect it to be protected by copyright. You don't need notice of copyright. You haven't since Jan. 1, 1978. If you publish without a notice, it doesn't mean stuff isn't protected. If I put my stuff on the Internet without notice, I can still sue if someone redistributes my RSS feed.
Even if you don't modify it, you have no right to copy it to your own site if the creator did not give the permission no matter what. Even if you give credit... The term 'legal' is not really relevant because its about copyright, and it would be handled as a case between two private persons/companies.
First, let me say that I agree that syndicating, not providing a link back, and changing sponsor codes is totally fucked and I do not agree with it. Now, with that said, on to my post.
Dirty Dane, syndicating via RSS is neither legal or illegal at this point because its never been tried in court. All talk on this subject is purely academic at this point. The honest truth, who ever has the most money for lawyer fees will win this battle. Better start saving...
Sig is on vacation... (I wish I could vacation as long as my sig has...)
Comment