Originally Posted by areagirls

According to the stats at Who Paid Me? ...

Kinky Dollars has the most popular shemale site, TS Seduction, which has an Alexa ranking of 6,572.

Next biggest are...

Niche Castle - Only T Girls
(9,740)

Niche Castle - Shemales Get Fucked
(9,918)

Niche Castle - Ass Toyed Shemales
(9,991)

Niche Castle - Shemale Revenge
(17,809)

Exotic Gold - Black Brazilian Shemales
(20,699)

Exotic Gold - Shemale Nova
(21,909)

So yeah, I'd place NicheCastle and Exotic Gold as the BangBros and Nastydollars of Shemale sites.

If you'd like to see the Top 100...

Top 100 Shemale Sites

You can use the Alexa filter on the right to narrow it down to sites with Alexa less than 50,000.

Be sure to set the 'Show gay sites?' filter to Yes.