Originally Posted by neewwman

I think we need to define "overrated."

To me "overrated" means: "critically acclaimed" + "not actually all that good."

Under this definition, Kiss and Poison are not "overrated" because they are not critically acclaimed or taken seriously. Maybe "undeservedly popular," but not "overrated."

The most overrated band of all time by a mile:

THE DOORS!

The Doors are hugely critically acclaimed, and they just plain sucked!