Originally Posted by Libertine

Hmm. Some good tips in this thread, but in my opinion, the most important one is missing:

Aim smaller.

Right now, it looks to me as if you are targetting the "big" search terms. Obviously, with a fairly new site that has relatively few backlinks and no perfect, focused seo strategy, it will be impossible to get clickable rankings (rankings that a significant amount of people actually reach).

Focus on a few small, not too obvious phrases at first. You should be able to get good/top rankings for those, and get more traffic than you'd get by competing with the big guys.