dig420, there's so much emotion in your post.
So... killing a creature in a humane fashion is different from torturing it before you kill it?
A dead creature is still dead.
I really don't think godisdead is advocating the extreme, excruciating, drawn out, <heart wrenching adjective>, <appeal to your emotions adjective>, <tear jerker adjective>, <terrifying adjective> killing as much as he's arguing against the precident it sets.
If you know law, you know precidents hold a massive fuck ton of weight.
That's the issue.