GoFuckYourself.com - Adult Webmaster Forum - View Single Post

Rambozo · 07-25-2006, 07:02 PM

It seems like there is some differences between the opinions of the different FSC lawyers I've read. One seems to say that since this is a new law, it changes everything. Another says that nothing has changed since the underlying law is already is under challenge and Judge Miller has issued an injunction.
Does the new law - HR 4426 - trump Judge Millers injunction and make it moot or not? Are secondary producers who are FSC members still exempt from inspections or not?
I know that some lawyers are saying that they won't comment since it hasn't been signed into law yet. Do you really think for 1 minute that Bush will not sign it? So for the sake of argument, ASSUME that he will.
Will the FSC challenge this new law? Or do they think that is unnecessary because of the appeal to the current law?

A lot of webmasters joined the FSC so that they could be exempt from inspections during the appeal process. Does the new law affect their status?
I for one would like to know the status BEFORE the new law is signed and goes into effect, not afterwards.
If there is some differences of opinions, then I think the FSC should make that clear and give us a best case/worse case scenario.
I was happy to pay my dues to the FSC for a membership but think it's time for their lawyers to step up a bit.

07-25-2006, 07:02 PM
Rambozo Confirmed User Join Date: Apr 2003 Posts: 117	Hey FSC! Whats the deal? It seems like there is some differences between the opinions of the different FSC lawyers I've read. One seems to say that since this is a new law, it changes everything. Another says that nothing has changed since the underlying law is already is under challenge and Judge Miller has issued an injunction. Does the new law - HR 4426 - trump Judge Millers injunction and make it moot or not? Are secondary producers who are FSC members still exempt from inspections or not? I know that some lawyers are saying that they won't comment since it hasn't been signed into law yet. Do you really think for 1 minute that Bush will not sign it? So for the sake of argument, ASSUME that he will. Will the FSC challenge this new law? Or do they think that is unnecessary because of the appeal to the current law? A lot of webmasters joined the FSC so that they could be exempt from inspections during the appeal process. Does the new law affect their status? I for one would like to know the status BEFORE the new law is signed and goes into effect, not afterwards. If there is some differences of opinions, then I think the FSC should make that clear and give us a best case/worse case scenario. I was happy to pay my dues to the FSC for a membership but think it's time for their lawyers to step up a bit.