I'd say it's too similar.
There are SO many ways to make review sites and no need to copy each other. Look at how different x3guide.com is for example. (And yes, we were the first review site out there apart from simple link-list-sites).
Plenty of sites copied our code and concepts (and it's no wonder why not many copied the design - as a coder I had to do the design myself and I can't do it for shit

), but I think you'd agree we're VERY different from for example TheBestPorn.
I'd have to side with Rick on this one. There's NO need to be so similar.
/Egon, x3guide