I like #2's hair and makeup better. I like the "Pmala Anderson I-just-got-out- of- bed" messy type hair and I like her eye makeup done all dark and smokey... I always do my own makeup like that so that's why I like it
#1 has a rounder face, I don't like round faces since my ideal for perfect beauty is an oval face. My face is kinda round too a bit and I don't like it!! #2 has a better looking face or perhaps it appears that way because it is covered by her hair.
#1 has a very cute outfit going on, perfect for clubbing... She looks like a go-go-dancer ...
I would guess that most guys would pick #1 though because they like the more "innocent" less pornstar-ish look. But I myself like #2!!