Originally Posted by blackmonsters

Some lawyer somewhere is going to blast a hole in 2257.
Not by defeating it directly but focusing heat on the "secondary producers/publishers".

The way I read 2257 a good legal argument can be made that the following are also secondary producers/publishers:

Local Cable TV (rebrocast Playboy chanel etc...)
Adult Video rentals/sales
Adult Film theaters
7-11 magazine section
etc...etc...

None of these have copies of ID's and they shouldn't because in reality they are not secondary producers or publishers. They are in fact Primary retailers.