Have to go with the second one too. Put's it all on one page. I'm changing some AVS sites cause the quicker ya get'em to the join page the better... I'm not in your league though at all... Many points of view on the subject.
If you go with the fist one, I'd change out the the third pic. A less MILF looking MILF. The up close of her face and hands makes her look older.... The point perhaps. Just my
Good luck with it.